ConvertKit (Now Kit) vs beehiiv for a Service Business Newsletter

Coding Liquids tutorial cover featuring Sagnik Bhattacharya for ConvertKit (Now Kit) vs beehiiv for a Service Business Newsletter.
Coding Liquids tutorial cover featuring Sagnik Bhattacharya for ConvertKit (Now Kit) vs beehiiv for a Service Business Newsletter.

Kit (ConvertKit's new name) suits most service businesses better than beehiiv: its tags, branching automations and Calendly app turn a newsletter into lead nurture that ends in booked calls. At 2,500 subscribers, automations cost $59 a month on Kit Creator against $79 on beehiiv Lite; beehiiv builds AI writing into its editor, while Kit connects your own AI tool.

The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration

From formulas and pivot tables to Power Query, DAX, VBA and AI with Copilot, ChatGPT and Claude — hands-on from the first lesson.

By Sagnik Bhattacharya and Virginia Thorn, Primetime Emmy Award winner

Buy now

Both free plans hold a 2,500-person list at $0, but neither sends an automated sequence: Kit Free has no Visual Automations or Sequences, and beehiiv Free runs no live automations. The answer flips towards beehiiv when the newsletter is the product itself, with a hosted website, referral rewards and ad income, or when you want AI writing included in the subscription.

Prices and plan features below were read on kit.com and beehiiv.com on 22 November 2026, on monthly billing unless stated. Both vendors change their pricing pages often, so treat the figures as a dated snapshot and check them before you commit.

Which platform fits a newsletter that has to win booked calls?

Kit fits a newsletter that must win booked calls better than beehiiv: Kit's automations react to sign-ups, tags, link clicks and purchases, and its App Store connects Calendly and SavvyCal. beehiiv was designed the other way round. Its plans centre on publishing: a hosted website, podcast hosting, a community space and a recommendation network on every plan, then an ad network and paid subscriptions from Lite upwards. Those features earn their keep when readers value the newsletter for its own sake. A service firm's newsletter usually has a narrower job: keep prospects warm until they need you, then make booking a call the obvious next step.

The table compares the two on the jobs a consultancy, adviser or agency actually needs done, using each vendor's own plan tables.

Job a service firm needs doneKitbeehiiv
Send a guide or checklist the moment someone signs upOpt-in incentive delivery on every plan, Free includedWelcome email on every plan, Free included
Tag people by the service they asked aboutTagging and segmentation on FreeTags inside automations from Lite; Free allows 3 segments and can't publish to a segment
Run a multi-email nurtureUnlimited Visual Automations and Sequences on Creator and Pro10 live automations on Lite, unlimited on Pro
React when someone clicks "book a call"Link Triggers on Creator and Pro tag the clicker or start a sequenceClick-triggered automations on Pro only
Connect a booking toolCalendly and SavvyCal apps in the Kit App Store; Acuity Scheduling among its listed integrationsNo scheduling app on its integrations page; Zapier, Make or the API instead
Look professional without the vendor's badgeKit branding removed from Creator ($59 a month at 2,500)beehiiv branding removed on Pro only ($149 a month at 2,500)
Built-in AI writingAI subject-line generator in broadcastsWriting assistant, tone changes, translation and images in the editor on Lite and Pro
Hosted archive and websiteNewsletter feed and site on every planWebsite builder, podcast and community on every plan
Team logins1 on Free, 2 on Creator, unlimited on Pro1 on Free, 2 on Lite, 10 on Pro

Two rows decide most service-business cases. The click row matters because "clicked the booking link but didn't book" is the warmest group on your list, and Kit lets you catch it on its middle plan while beehiiv asks for Pro. The branding row matters because a firm selling expertise rarely wants a vendor's badge under a proposal follow-up. If neither row matters to you, the choice is closer than most comparisons suggest, and the cost section below settles it.

For the plan-by-plan detail on each side, see Kit's free plan limits and Creator costs and what beehiiv's Free, Lite and Pro plans cost a business.

How much do Kit and beehiiv cost at 2,500 subscribers?

Kit and beehiiv both cost $0 for 2,500 subscribers on their free plans; with automations, Kit Creator costs $59 a month and beehiiv Lite $79 a month on monthly billing. The gap widens just above that size, because the two vendors draw their price bands in different places. Kit's Creator band runs from 1,001 to 3,000 subscribers, while beehiiv's Lite price steps up at 2,501.

SubscribersKit FreeKit CreatorKit Probeehiiv Freebeehiiv Litebeehiiv Pro
1,000$0$39$79$0$59$109
2,500$0$59$99$0$79$149
5,000$0$89$139Over the 2,500 cap$109$199
10,000$0$139$189Over the 2,500 cap$139$239

Yearly billing lowers both. beehiiv publishes yearly totals: Lite costs $828 a year at up to 2,500 subscribers (about $69 a month) and $1,140 at up to 5,000, while Pro costs $1,548 a year at up to 2,500. Its pricing FAQ puts the yearly saving at up to 20%. Kit says paying yearly saves 17%, so confirm its exact yearly figure at checkout before you build a budget on it.

Counting rules differ a little too. Kit counts only unique, active subscribers and moves you to the next band automatically when you pass a limit; moving down again means contacting its support team. beehiiv counts unique email addresses subscribed to your publication. On either platform, unsubscribing people who haven't opened anything in months is the cheapest way to stay in a lower band, and Kit even has an Unsubscribe action in Visual Automations for pruning cold subscribers.

A quick sum shows where the bands bite. Take a list that hovers between 2,600 and 2,900 all year. Kit Creator stays at $59 a month, or $708 for twelve months. beehiiv Lite has moved into its $109 band, or $1,308 for the same twelve months on monthly billing, and $1,140 if you pay for the 5,000 band yearly. The same list costs $432 to $600 more a year on beehiiv Lite before anyone has written a word. Add one line to the Kit column, though: Kit's writing help beyond subject lines comes from your own AI assistant, so if nobody on the team has one yet, its subscription belongs in the comparison.

What can a service business do on Kit Free or beehiiv Free?

Kit Free and beehiiv Free both send unlimited emails plus a sign-up email, but neither runs a nurture sequence; beehiiv Free caps the list at 2,500, Kit Free at 10,000. Beyond that, the two free plans give away different things.

Kit Free, up to 10,000 subscribers

  • Unlimited landing pages and forms, with your own domain connected if you want branded pages.
  • Broadcasts to the whole list or to tagged groups, with tagging and segmentation included.
  • Automatic delivery of a sign-up freebie, such as a PDF checklist.
  • Conditional content written in Liquid, Kit's template language, so one broadcast can show different paragraphs to different tags.
  • Subject-line A/B tests with two variants, and five uses of the AI subject-line generator.
  • Digital products and recurring subscriptions at 3.5% plus 30 cents per sale, card processing included.
  • Missing: Visual Automations, Sequences, Link Triggers, App Store apps, the Kit MCP and branding removal. One user only.

beehiiv Free, up to 2,500 subscribers

  • A hosted website with one custom page, subscribe forms and a link-in-bio page.
  • A welcome email, custom fields and up to three segments.
  • Campaign analytics with a 30-day look-back window.
  • One digital product, plus podcast hosting and a community space.
  • Read-only access for the beehiiv MCP and beehiiv Agent, so an AI assistant can look at your data but not change it.
  • Missing: live automations, publishing to segments, in-editor beehiiv AI, custom domains, A/B tests and branding removal. One seat only.

A two-adviser financial planning practice with 900 subscribers and one monthly market note can run happily on either free plan. The trouble starts with the first follow-up. Say the practice publishes a pension checklist and wants three emails over ten days after each download. Kit Free delivers the checklist but can't send emails two and three; beehiiv Free sends a welcome email and nothing after it. Both vendors want a paid plan for that second email, so price the paid tier on day one rather than after the first campaign.

The caps behave differently as the list grows. Kit Free keeps working to 10,000 subscribers, so a firm that only ever sends broadcasts can stay on it until the list passes that size. beehiiv Free holds 2,500, and the cheapest paid option for a 2,501-person list is Lite's $109 band, because the $79 price covers only lists of up to 2,500. A practice at 2,300 subscribers and growing should run that sum before choosing.

How do Kit and beehiiv automations handle lead nurture?

Kit Creator runs unlimited Visual Automations that branch on tags, link clicks, purchases and custom fields, while beehiiv Lite allows 10 live automations and keeps click triggers for its Pro plan.

Kit splits the work into two pieces. A Sequence is a set of emails sent on a schedule; a Visual Automation decides who enters which Sequence and what happens next. An automation starts from up to five entry points (joins a form, tag is added, a custom field change or a purchase) and then uses three kinds of step: events that pull a subscriber forward when something happens, actions that do something to them, and conditions that send them down one branch or another. Kit's six actions are adding to an email sequence, a delay, moving the subscriber into or out of an automation, adding or removing a tag, setting a custom field, and unsubscribing.

beehiiv's Lite plan builds the same kind of journey from a different list. Triggers include signing up, submitting a form, entering or leaving a segment, a tag being added or removed, a survey reply, a purchase, a custom field changing and a subscriber going unengaged. Actions include sending an email, waiting, adding or removing a tag, updating a custom field, starting another automation and a true-or-false branch. Pro adds click-triggered automations, A/B splits and advanced conditions, and lifts the cap of 10 live automations.

The practical difference for a service firm is the click. A prospect who clicks "book a 20-minute call" in email four and then gets distracted is worth a personal note the same day. Kit's Link Triggers, on Creator and Pro, tag that person the moment they click. On beehiiv you need Pro for a click to start an automation, or a booking tool that reports back through Zapier, Make or the API; the pattern for that is in turning Calendly bookings into CRM records with Zapier.

Here is a filled-in five-email nurture for an HR consultancy whose sign-up offer is an absence-policy checklist. The subjects and timings are illustrative; the structure is the part to copy.

EmailSendsSubject lineJobLink
1At sign-upYour absence-policy checklistDeliver the guide and one quick tipChecklist download
2Day 2The three absence cases small firms handle badlyShow judgement through short scenariosA longer article on your site
3Day 5What a return-to-work meeting should coverA practical template, then a soft offer"Book a 20-minute call" (Link Trigger, tag clicked-booking)
CheckAfter email 3Condition: has the tag call-booked?Yes: exit the automation. No: carry onNone
4Day 9What a fixed-fee policy review includesDescribe the paid service and its usual scopeBooking link (Link Trigger)
5Day 14Shall we keep in touch monthly?Move them to the monthly newsletterPreferences page

If you'd rather draft the emails themselves with AI help first, building a welcome email sequence with AI covers the writing side; the rest of this section is about the wiring.

Building the nurture flow in Kit, click by click

The build takes an afternoon once the five emails are written. Menu names follow Kit's help centre, and every step needs Creator or Pro.

  1. Create the sign-up form for the checklist and set its incentive email to deliver the file.
  2. Write emails one to three as a Sequence called "Absence nurture A", and emails four and five as "Absence nurture B".
  3. Go to Rules under the Automation tab in the left navigation, click + New rule, choose the trigger Clicks a link, name it "Booking click", enter your booking page as the destination and add the action that applies the tag clicked-booking. Save it.
  4. In emails three and four, highlight the booking text, click the link icon and pick the Link Trigger from the dropdown instead of typing a URL.
  5. Go to Automations under the Automation tab, click + New automation, choose Start from scratch, then Start building.
  6. Set the entry point to Joins a form and pick the checklist form.
  7. Add an action: Email sequence, "Absence nurture A".
  8. Add a condition that checks for the tag call-booked. On the yes branch, add Move subscriber, then Exit this automation. On the no branch, add the action Email sequence, "Absence nurture B".
  9. Connect your booking tool so that a confirmed booking adds the call-booked tag. The Kit App Store describes its Calendly app as able to automate workflows when meetings are booked; run a test booking and check which tag or event it produces before you rely on it.
  10. Click the Active toggle at the top right of the builder. Kit autosaves as you go, but nothing runs until that toggle is on.

Two Kit behaviours catch people out. A subscriber moves to the next automation step only after receiving the last email in a Sequence, so someone who books after email one still gets emails two and three; keeping Sequence A to three emails limits the damage, and the condition then stops emails four and five. And automations don't work retroactively: the 400 people who downloaded the checklist last month won't enter a flow you switch on today, so send them a one-off broadcast with the same offer.

For the warm group who clicked but didn't book, a short personal note beats another automated email. Filter subscribers who have clicked-booking but not call-booked once a day and send something like this from your own inbox:

Subject: Finding a time

Hi [first name],

Quick note in case the booking page didn't show a slot that suits.
If you reply with two times that work for you this week or next,
I'll fit the 20-minute call around them.

[your name]

How does AI help compare between Kit and beehiiv?

Kit and beehiiv take opposite routes to AI: beehiiv builds a writing assistant into its editor on paid plans, while Kit offers a subject-line generator and connects your own assistant through the Kit MCP.

beehiiv's in-editor AI covers drafting from a prompt, spell checking, shortening or extending sentences, changing tone, translating and generating images, all from an AI block inside the post editor. Its plan table lists that in-editor AI on Lite and Pro only, and describes the included AI usage as "Limited" on Free, "Elevated" on Lite and "5x Lite" on Pro, without publishing credit numbers. A beehiiv trial runs AI in the post editor at Lite's credit limits. For a walk-through of that editor, see drafting a weekly issue with beehiiv AI.

Kit says it would rather connect well with outside AI tools than build AI into every corner of its product. Inside Kit you get the AI subject-line generator: write the broadcast, click the sparkle icon beside the subject field, and choose from five suggestions or A/B test two or more of them. It works on Broadcasts, not Sequences, is unlimited on paid plans and gives Free accounts five uses. For drafting, the Kit MCP (Model Context Protocol, a standard way for an AI assistant to read and act on another app's data) connects Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini to your Kit account on Creator and Pro. Kit says the MCP itself is free to connect; the assistant is a separate subscription. Apps in the Kit App Store, such as Lex, add drafting tools at each app's own price.

AI questionKitbeehiiv
Writing help inside the editorSubject lines only, in BroadcastsDrafts, rewrites, tone, translation and images on Lite and Pro
AllowanceSubject lines unlimited on paid plans, five uses on Free"Limited" on Free, "Elevated" on Lite, "5x Lite" on Pro; no credit numbers published
Use your own assistantKit MCP on Creator and Probeehiiv MCP: read on Free, write on Lite and Pro
Extra costYour assistant's subscription; some App Store appsNothing beyond the plan, within its allowance

Whichever route you choose, the first draft needs a service-business edit. Here is a prompt that works in beehiiv's AI block or in any assistant you connect to Kit, followed by an illustrative output and the fixes I'd make.

Write email 3 of a 5-email nurture for an HR consultancy.
Reader: owner or office manager of a 10-50 person firm who
downloaded our absence-policy checklist 5 days ago.
Goal: one practical tip on return-to-work meetings, then an
invitation to book a free 20-minute call.
Tone: plain, calm, no hype. 150 words maximum.
One link only: [booking link].
Do not promise outcomes, quote laws or invent statistics.

Illustrative output: "Return-to-work meetings are your best chance to spot a problem early. Keep them short, private and within two days of the person coming back. Ask how they are, whether anything at work contributed, and what would help this week. Note what you agreed and when you'll check in. If you'd like a second pair of eyes on your absence process, book a free 20-minute call here: [booking link]. Most firms leave with two or three changes they can make the same week."

What to fix: "within two days" is a policy choice that belongs to the client, so soften it to "soon after they return"; the last sentence promises an outcome, which the prompt banned, so cut it; and the booking line needs a reason to act now, such as the two slots you keep free each week for new enquiries. One more catch on Kit: the subject-line generator doesn't run inside Sequences, so for nurture emails ask your assistant for five subject lines in the same chat and pick the plainest.

Worked choice: a six-person HR consultancy at 2,500 subscribers

Here is the whole decision for one illustrative firm. A six-person HR consultancy has 2,500 subscribers from two downloadable guides and past enquiries, and gains about 60 a month. Two people write and send. The brief: a monthly newsletter, the five-email nurture above, no vendor badge on emails, and a daily list of people who clicked the booking link without booking.

At 60 a month, the list stays at or under 3,000 for the first nine months and reaches about 3,160 by month twelve. The year-one sums below follow each vendor's published price bands for the list size in each month.

OptionMeets the brief?How the year adds upYear one
Kit Creator, monthlyYes: branding off, Link Triggers, unlimited automations9 months at $59, then 3 at $89$798
beehiiv Lite, monthlyPartly: beehiiv branding stays, no click triggers1 month at $79, then 11 at $109$1,278
beehiiv Lite, yearly at the 5,000 bandPartly, as aboveOne payment$1,140
beehiiv Pro, monthlyYes, with in-editor AI at the higher allowance1 month at $149, then 11 at $199$2,338
beehiiv Pro, yearly at the 5,000 bandYesOne payment$2,028

Kit Creator meets the whole brief for $798. The cheapest beehiiv option that meets it is Pro paid yearly at $2,028, a gap of $1,230. Part of that gap goes on AI for the Kit route if neither writer has an assistant subscription, but even a paid assistant for both writers leaves most of it in place. Set-up time is similar on both platforms. As a rough planning figure, allow about three hours to write and check five emails with AI help, two to wire the automation and Link Triggers, and one more to test the flow with two spare email addresses.

What would change the answer? If the same firm wanted a fuller website, a podcast feed and in-editor AI for a junior marketer under one login, beehiiv Pro's higher price starts to buy things Kit doesn't offer in one place. If it only wanted the monthly newsletter and no nurture at all, Kit Free would carry the list to 10,000 subscribers at no cost.

If you want help fitting a nurture sequence into how your consultancy runs, I offer one-to-one AI consultations for small businesses.

When does beehiiv beat Kit for a service business?

beehiiv beats Kit for a service business when the newsletter is a publication in its own right, when paid one-to-one sessions are sold through it, or when AI writing should come with the plan.

The first case is the adviser whose commentary is the marketing. A financial adviser who publishes a weekly market note that clients forward to friends gets more from beehiiv's website builder, recommendation network and podcast hosting than from Kit's branching automations, because readers find the archive and subscribe from it. The nurture can stay simple: a welcome email and one follow-up. Check your own compliance rules on AI-drafted commentary before the AI block writes a word of it.

The second case is paid strategy sessions. beehiiv's digital products include a coaching or one-to-one type for paid strategy calls, listed on Pro, and beehiiv takes 0% of the sale, leaving Stripe's 2.9% plus $0.30. Kit sells digital products and recurring subscriptions such as coaching packages on every plan at 3.5% plus 30 cents, card fees included. On a $250 session that is $7.55 against $9.05, so beehiiv saves $1.50 a sale but needs Pro to do it; for a firm selling 10 sessions a month, the fee saving is $15 against a plan that costs $149 to $199 a month at 2,500 to 5,000 subscribers. The fee alone never justifies the switch.

The third case is a B2B software reseller whose marketing assistant writes the monthly update and also sends a translated version to a second-language customer group. beehiiv's in-editor translation and tone tools on Lite cover that job without a separate AI subscription, which Kit's route would need.

Which mistakes cost service firms leads on either platform?

The costliest mistakes are emailing people who have already booked, crossing beehiiv Free's 2,500 cap in the middle of a campaign, and sending AI-written promises the service can't keep.

  • Nurturing people who already booked. It shows up as replies like "we're already speaking on Thursday" and the odd unsubscribe from your warmest prospects. Fix it with a call-booked tag, a condition after the first short Sequence and an exit branch, as in the build above.
  • Building the nurture during beehiiv's trial. beehiiv's 14-day Pro trial lets you run up to 10 live automations, but its help centre says Pro features turn off if the account stays on Free when the trial ends. The flow you tested quietly stops. Decide on the paid plan before the trial's last day.
  • Hitting a price band mid-launch. A firm at 2,450 subscribers on beehiiv Lite runs a guide launch, adds 300 people in a week and moves from the $79 band to $109. Check the next band before any campaign that could add more than a few hundred sign-ups, and prune cold subscribers first.
  • Subject lines that oversell. An AI suggestion such as "Fix your absence problem this week" gets opens, then unsubscribes when the email offers a checklist. Read every subject line next to its email and cut any promise the body doesn't keep.
  • Tag sprawl. After six months the account holds "HR-absence", "absence_hr" and "Absence Policy", and the booking condition checks only one of them. Agree a naming pattern on day one, such as interest-absence and status-booked, and keep the list of tags in a shared note.
  • Importing old client lists without consent. A spreadsheet of past enquiries is not a mailing list. Import only people who agreed to hear from you, and record where each came from so you can show it later.

How do you know the platform is paying off after 90 days?

A newsletter platform is paying off when booked calls per 100 new subscribers beat the months before the nurture went live and each booked call costs far less than one client is worth. Write the before figures down on the day you switch the automation on, then fill in the after column at day 90.

Measure (illustrative HR firm)3 months before90 days afterWhere to find it
New subscribers180190Kit list growth report or beehiiv subscriber metrics
Clicked the booking linkNot tracked21Count of the clicked-booking tag
Calls booked from email27Booking tool, filtered by source
Booked calls per 100 new subscribers1.13.7Calls divided by new subscribers, times 100
Unsubscribes during the nurtureNot tracked9Each nurture email's stats
Platform cost for the period$0$177Kit Creator at $59 for three months
Cost per booked callNot trackedAbout $25Cost divided by calls

If pulling these figures into a spreadsheet each month is the slow part, try The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration on Coding Liquids.

Read the scorecard in order. If clicks rose but bookings didn't, the booking page is the problem: too few slots, too many questions, or a call length that feels like a commitment. If clicks stayed flat, the emails are the problem, and email three's offer is the first thing to rewrite. If unsubscribes jumped on one email, read its subject line against its body. Change the emails before you change the platform: moving 2,500 subscribers with their tags and automations takes real time on either side, and the same weak email will underperform on both.

Kit and beehiiv questions service firms ask

Is Kit the same company as ConvertKit?

Yes. ConvertKit renamed itself Kit, and kit.com still describes the product as formerly ConvertKit. Forms, Sequences, Visual Automations and tags all carry over under the new name. Some help articles still call the top plan Creator Pro while the pricing page calls it Pro, so read both names as the same plan. Prices have changed since the rename, so check kit.com rather than an old ConvertKit review.

Can beehiiv's free plan send a welcome sequence?

No. beehiiv Free sends a single welcome email but runs no live automations, so a sequence of two or more emails needs Lite, from $59 a month for up to 1,000 subscribers or $79 for up to 2,500, or Pro. You can build automations during the 14-day Pro trial, but beehiiv's help centre says Pro features turn off if the account stays on Free afterwards.

Does Kit charge extra for its AI features?

No extra plan fee. Kit's AI subject-line generator is unlimited on paid plans and gives Free accounts five uses, and Kit says the Kit MCP is free to connect, although its pricing table lists the MCP on Creator and Pro only. You pay separately for the assistant you connect, and Kit App Store apps set their own prices, some free and some paid.

Which is cheaper at 5,000 subscribers, Kit or beehiiv?

Kit is cheaper at 5,000 subscribers on monthly billing. Kit Creator costs $89 a month against beehiiv Lite at $109, and Kit Pro costs $139 against beehiiv Pro at $199. beehiiv Free cannot hold 5,000 subscribers, while Kit Free can, without automations. Both discount yearly billing: Kit says 17%, beehiiv says up to 20%, which brings Lite to $1,140 a year at that size.

Can I sell paid consultations through Kit or beehiiv?

Yes, on different terms. Kit lets every plan, Free included, sell digital products and recurring subscriptions such as coaching packages at 3.5% plus 30 cents a sale, card fees included. beehiiv offers coaching and one-to-one products on Pro, takes nothing itself and passes on Stripe's 2.9% plus $0.30. Free discovery calls still sit better in a booking tool such as Calendly.

Will Kit move my list and automations over from beehiiv?

Kit offers free migration on its paid plans: its pricing table says an in-house team rebuilds your forms, templates and automations when you move from another platform. The Free plan doesn't include it. Export your beehiiv subscribers first (data exports are on every beehiiv plan), and keep a note of which sign-up form each person came from so the new Kit tags match.

Further reads

Sources: Kit pricing page (plan table and price slider), Kit AI and Visual Automations pages, Kit App Store, Kit help centre articles on the AI subject line generator, Visual Automations, actions, events and Link Triggers; beehiiv pricing page and its published plan data, beehiiv AI, automations, digital products and integrations pages, and beehiiv's free-trial help article. All read 22 November 2026.

Rather not work this out alone?

An AI implementation consultation is a one-to-one call with me, not an agency or a sales team. You leave knowing what AI you can use in your business and where to start.

Book a 1:1 call with me