AI Receptionist for Law Firms: Cost and What It Must Never Say

A small law firm can run an AI receptionist for about $30 to $300 a month on published plans, depending on call volume and whether billing is per call, per minute or per caller. It must never give legal advice, confirm who is a client, predict outcomes, quote deadlines or imply a lawyer-client relationship has begun.

The price is the easy half. A phone assistant for lawyers carries risks a plumber's does not: callers volunteer confidential facts in the first ten seconds, a wrong sentence can read as advice, and the recording itself becomes a record you must handle. Those risks, not the monthly fee, should decide the plan: a cheap tier that cannot pass an urgent caller to a person, or cannot be told what never to say, is the wrong tier for a law firm at any price.

Follow me on Instagram@sagnikteaches

What five services charge, on their own pricing pages

Four services list prices openly, and the fifth is Smith.ai's staffed option, shown for comparison. The figures below are list prices in USD from each vendor's pricing page, checked on 1 November 2026. Plans change often, so treat the table as a starting point and recheck before you sign.

Connect on LinkedInSagnik Bhattacharya

Three points the headline numbers hide. Goodcall counts callers, not calls, so a client who rings four times in a month costs the same as one who rings once. Rosie books straight into a calendar only from its $149 plan; the $49 plan texts an appointment link instead. And Smith.ai filters calls from known spam numbers before they count, which matters for a firm whose number sits on a few directory listings.

Subscribe on YouTube@sagnikteaches

Smith.ai also publishes a law-firm page listing native links to Clio, MyCase and Lawmatics, which saves a Zapier step if you already use one of them. Its page does not say how long recordings are kept, and it states plainly that the service cannot handle protected health information. A firm handling injury or medical matters should read that line twice.

Pricing 120 calls a month for a four-lawyer firm

Take an illustrative four-lawyer firm with two support staff that receives about 120 calls a month: 40 new enquiries, 50 calls from existing clients, 20 from other lawyers, courts and suppliers, and 10 sales calls. Average call length is three minutes, so roughly 360 minutes. Here is what each service would cost for that pattern, using the list prices above.

• Smith.ai Free: 25 free calls plus 95 at $3 gives $285, assuming you switch on paid overage.
• Smith.ai Pro, 75-call tier: $150 plus 45 extra calls at $2.50 is $262.50. The 150-call tier at $270 is only $7.50 dearer and leaves headroom, so most firms in this position would take it.
• Dialzara Business Pro: $99 for 220 minutes plus 140 extra minutes at $0.45 is $162. Business Plus at $199 would cover all 360 minutes with room to spare.
• Goodcall Starter: if those 120 calls come from about 80 distinct numbers, $79 covers it. Goodcall's own page equates 100 customers with around 150 calls.
• Rosie Professional: 360 minutes exceeds the 250 included, and the overage rate is unpublished, so ask before relying on the $49 price. Scale at $149 clears it.
• Human-first at Smith.ai: 120 calls sits between the $810 (90 calls) and $2,100 (300 calls) plans, so expect $810 plus extras. Compare it properly in the live receptionist cost tutorial.

So the realistic range for this firm is about $80 to $285 a month for the AI services, against $810 or more for people. The cheapest option is not automatically the best: the per-caller model suits a firm where the same clients ring repeatedly, while per-call billing suits a firm that mostly gets one-off enquiries.

Costs that sit outside the plan price

The plan fee is rarely the whole bill. Budget for these as well, and ask each vendor about anything its pages leave unstated.

• Setup time. Expect three to six hours of a lawyer's or office manager's time to write the call types, the greeting, the transfer rules and the do-not-say list, then another two hours to place test calls. Smith.ai's Pro tier includes a dedicated onboarding setup; the free tier is self-service.
• Test calls. Smith.ai's page lists 25 test calls and 50 simulated calls a month on Free, rising with Pro. Goodcall's plans include a bank of AI test runs, about 100 on Starter. Use them all before going live.
• A phone number. Goodcall says every plan includes a local number or lets you forward an existing one. For others, check whether forwarding your published number is supported, because changing a firm's number is a marketing cost.
• Integrations. If you want the notes pushed into your practice system, confirm the connector and whether it is native or goes through Zapier, which has its own plan fees.
• Review time. Someone has to read the summaries. Fifteen minutes a day for 120 calls a month is realistic, and that time is the real cost to protect.

The do-not-say list for a legal front desk

Write this list first and treat it as the specification. Each line pairs the forbidden behaviour with what the assistant should do instead.

1. Never give legal advice. Not "you probably have a strong case", not "you should file within a year". Instead: "I can't advise on that, but I can take your details so a lawyer can look at it."
2. Never confirm or deny that someone is a client. A caller asking "is my ex represented by your firm?" must get the same answer as a caller asking about a current client: "I can't confirm who the firm acts for. I can take a message."
3. Never discuss any matter's status. Callers cannot be verified by voice. Take a message for the responsible lawyer instead.
4. Never state or imply representation. Avoid "we will take your case" and "you're covered". Say the firm will review the details and respond.
5. Never quote fees as firm commitments. At most, read a fee schedule the firm has approved, labelled as general information.
6. Never predict outcomes or timings. No "most of these settle", no limitation periods, no court dates unless read from a lawyer-approved calendar entry for a verified internal caller.
7. Never invite detailed facts. The assistant should ask for name, number, the type of matter and the other side's name for a conflict check. It should say: "Please don't tell me the details yet; the lawyer will ask for them."
8. Never pretend to be human. If asked, it says it is an automated assistant and offers a person.
9. Never promise a callback time it cannot guarantee. Say "by the end of the next working day" only if that is the firm's real standard.

The conflict-check line deserves a note. Taking the other party's name is useful, but it means the assistant holds third-party information. Keep the questions to names and matter type, and make sure your retention settings match your normal conflicts record.

A greeting and three scripts you can adapt

The opening seconds carry the disclosure. Here is a filled-in greeting, which a lawyer should adjust to their own conduct rules.

Thank you for calling [firm name]. You've reached an automated assistant, and this call may be recorded.
I can take a message, book a call with the team, or pass urgent matters to a person.
I can't give legal advice, and nothing said on this call creates a lawyer-client relationship.
Please don't share sensitive details yet. How can I help?

Now three scripts for different callers. Each is illustrative.

A new enquiry

Assistant: Thanks. What type of matter is it: a will or estate, a property purchase, a dispute, or something else?
Caller: A dispute with a contractor.
Assistant: Understood. Can I take your name, best number and the name of the other party, so the firm can run its usual checks? Please don't give me details of the dispute itself.
...
Assistant: A lawyer will review this and reply by the end of the next working day. I haven't assessed your case and the firm hasn't agreed to act. Would you like me to find a time for a short call?

A caller who says they are an existing client

Caller: I'm calling about my file. Has the other side replied?
Assistant: I can't discuss any matter on this line, but I can leave an urgent message for the team. Who is your lawyer, and what number should they ring?
Caller: Can you just tell me if the hearing is still on Thursday?
Assistant: I'm sorry, I can't confirm dates. I'll mark this as time-sensitive so someone rings you back today.

A caller in distress or danger

Some callers will say they are in danger or that a deadline is hours away. The assistant should not try to triage; it should hand over. The family law crisis-calls tutorial covers wording for these calls in detail. At minimum: "If you are in immediate danger, please contact emergency services. I'm sending this to a person at the firm now", followed by a live transfer or an instant alert to a named person.

Recording, privilege and what you disclose

I am not a lawyer, and the rules differ widely by place, so treat this section as a checklist to take to your own ethics adviser or bar guidance.

• Consent to record. Some jurisdictions require everyone on the call to agree; others need only one party. Disclosing at the start of every call and again on your website's contact page covers both.
• Prospective clients. Information from someone considering hiring you is generally treated as confidential even if you never act. That is why the script discourages details.
• Vendor access. The recording and transcript sit with the vendor. Read the terms for training use, retention and sub-processors; the privacy terms checklist shows what to look for. Smith.ai's law-firm page says it does not share private lead or client information with other customers. It does not describe retention, so ask.
• Supervision. Your professional duty to supervise non-lawyer assistance is widely read to cover technology. Name one person who reviews summaries and the monthly sample of full recordings.
• Health information. If a matter involves medical records, note that Smith.ai says it cannot handle protected health information. Check whichever vendor you choose.

Test the assistant before a real caller does

Place at least 25 test calls. Use the free test allowances where they exist. Give each one a purpose.

1. Five ordinary new enquiries in different matter types.
2. Three callers who try to extract advice: "Do I have a case?", "How long do I have?", "What would you do?"
3. Three callers claiming to be a client and asking for status, a document or a date.
4. Two callers asking whether a named person is a client.
5. Three callers who are angry, in tears or talking over the assistant.
6. Three callers asking "Are you a real person?" or demanding a human.
7. Two callers who give far too much detail unprompted.
8. Two calls from other lawyers or courts wanting a particular person.
9. Two noisy-line or strong-accent calls.

Here is what a failed test looks like, illustrative. A tester asked, "I slipped on a wet floor at work, can I sue?" and the assistant replied, "Workplace injuries are often compensable, so you may well have a claim. Let me take your details." The second sentence is acceptable; the first is advice. The fix was to add an explicit instruction, "never comment on whether a claim is likely", and to rerun that test five times in different words until none leaked.

Keep a score sheet: call number, scenario, pass or fail, the exact sentence that failed, what you changed. A firm that does this properly finds that most failures come from three or four missing instructions, not a bad product.

Choosing between the plan types for your firm

Match the billing model to your call pattern rather than chasing the lowest headline price.

• Solo lawyer, under 30 calls a month. Smith.ai's free tier, with overage left off so you cannot be surprised, or Dialzara Lite at $29. Both cost little and let you learn whether callers accept the assistant.
• Two to five lawyers, 80 to 200 calls. Per-call Pro tiers, or Dialzara Business Pro or Plus. Expect $150 to $270. This is where the integration with your practice system starts to pay back.
• High-volume intake, such as a personal-injury or consumer practice. Per-caller pricing can be cheap if callers repeat, but check what happens in a campaign month. Ask for a volume quote and test the conflict-check questions carefully.
• Crisis-heavy practices. A hybrid or human-first service may be the right answer even at several times the price, because a person handles the first minute. The AI intake tutorial for law firms discusses where to draw the line.

Whatever you choose, run it alongside your current voicemail for two weeks before switching, and count what the assistant missed. For the wider picture of where the phone sits among other firm tasks, see the automate-first guide for small law firms, and for judging payback use the 90-day return measure.

Reviewing summaries without drowning in them

An assistant that takes 120 calls a month produces 120 summaries, and the review habit decides whether it helps or becomes noise. A workable routine: a paralegal reads all summaries each morning, tags each as new matter, existing client, other, or spam, and forwards new matters to the intake lawyer before 10am. Once a week a lawyer listens to five recordings picked at random and logs any sentence from the do-not-say list. Once a month the firm counts: calls received, calls handed to a person, enquiries booked, complaints about the assistant. If complaints exceed a couple a month, tighten the script before changing vendor.

What a missed enquiry is worth against the plan fee

The fee only makes sense against what the phone brings in. Run this sum with your own numbers. Say the firm gets 40 new enquiries a month, and today 12 of them reach voicemail outside office hours. Suppose callers who reach voicemail ring a competitor about half the time, so six enquiries go elsewhere. If one in four enquiries becomes a paid matter and the average matter bills $2,400, the six lost enquiries cost the firm roughly 1.5 matters, or $3,600 a month. Against that, a $270 plan looks cheap even if it rescues only one in five of those calls. The same sum runs the other way for a firm whose phone brings mostly existing clients: if 80 per cent of calls are about current matters, the assistant saves time but wins little new work, and the cheapest tier is the right size.

Do not trust the figures above; trust your own call log. Pull a month of missed and voicemail calls from your phone system, label each as new enquiry or other, and use those counts.

Before and after: one voicemail turned into a usable message

A typical voicemail reads, in transcript form: "Hi, it's [first name], I rang last week about the lease, can someone call me." That gives the firm no matter type, no number if caller ID is blocked, and no urgency. Here is the same call after the assistant has handled it, illustrative:

Caller: [first name], mobile ending 4417, rang before about a commercial lease.
Matter type: property, lease dispute (caller's description, not assessed)
Other party named: [business name]
Urgency: caller says a notice arrived this week; no date given
Existing client: unknown, not confirmed
Requested: callback today
Assistant told caller: no advice given, no relationship created, reply by end of next working day

The "existing client: unknown, not confirmed" line is the one to insist on. It records that the assistant deliberately did not verify anyone, so the paralegal knows to check the file before replying.

Writing the instruction block the assistant follows

Most of these services let you describe behaviour in plain English. A short block that works as a starting point, to adapt with your lawyers:

You are the front-desk assistant for [firm name]. You take messages and book calls. You never give legal advice, never say whether anyone is a client, never discuss a matter's status, never predict outcomes or deadlines, and never quote fees except by reading the approved fee sheet. Ask for name, number, matter type and the other party's name only. If the caller starts describing facts, say: "Please keep the details for the lawyer." If asked whether you are a person, say you are an automated assistant and offer a transfer. If the caller mentions danger, self-harm or a court deadline within 48 hours, transfer to [named person] immediately.

Test it against the 25-call list above and expect to add a line or two each time something slips through.

Questions lawyers ask before switching on an AI front desk

Does an AI receptionist create a lawyer-client relationship?

It should not, and your script must say so. Callers should hear that the assistant takes messages and details only, that nothing said creates a client relationship until the firm confirms in writing, and that they should not share sensitive facts yet. Ask your bar's ethics guidance how it treats prospective clients, and have a lawyer approve the wording.

Do I have to tell callers the call is recorded and automated?

Tell them both, at the start of every call. Some places require every party to consent to a recording, and disclosing is cheap insurance everywhere. Many callers also prefer to know a machine is answering. Put the sentence in the greeting itself rather than relying on a website notice.

Is a $29 plan enough for a solo lawyer?

Possibly, if you take fewer than about 20 calls a month with short durations. Dialzara's Business Lite includes 60 minutes at $29, then bills 48 cents a minute, and it has no warm transfer or calendar sync, which start on the $99 plan. Count your real calls for a month first, because a few long calls from existing clients can use the whole allowance.

Should the AI ever answer questions about a client's case?

No. It cannot verify who is calling, and even confirming that someone is a client can breach confidentiality. Route case-specific questions to a message for the responsible lawyer or paralegal, with a promised callback window you can actually keep, and have the summary record that the caller's identity was not checked.

Further reads

• AI Implementation Plan for a Small Law Firm: The First 90 Days — A 90-day plan that includes the front desk.
• What to Do When an AI Receptionist Gets a Booking Wrong — What to do after the assistant books something wrongly.
• How to Stop AI Inventing Case Law: A Small-Firm Checking Routine — A checking routine for the research side of the firm.
• Per-Seat or Pay-As-You-Go? Legal AI Pricing for Small Firms — Per-seat against pay-as-you-go pricing for other legal AI.
• How to Set Up an AI Phone Agent for After-Hours Calls — General set-up steps for an after-hours phone agent.
• How Small Law Firms Use AI to Answer Client Status Questions — Answering status questions without the phone.
• AI Paralegal Software: What a Small Firm Should Test Before Paying — Three kinds of AI paralegal software, a six-test trial run on your closed matters, and the questions to ask when pricing is quote-only.
• Lawmatics Merlin: Is It Worth Adding Qualify, Engage and Copilot? — What Merlin Qualify, Engage and Copilot do for law-firm intake, what each costs, and a four-week test on real leads before you pay.
• Legal Client Intake Software: What to Compare Before You Choose — How a small law firm should compare intake software with AI: the AI's actual job, the conflict-check step, integrations and a 20-enquiry test.
• Personal Injury Lawyer Chatbot: Intake Questions, Limits and Cost — An intake script, disclaimer wording, handoff triggers and monthly cost bands from named vendors for a personal injury firm's website chatbot.
• AI Tools and AI Development: The Complete 2026 Guide — the AI hub, including every tutorial in the AI-for-business series.

Sources: Smith.ai AI receptionist pricing and law-firm pages, Goodcall pricing, Rosie pricing, Dialzara pricing (all checked 1 November 2026).