Performance Max vs AI Max: Which Suits a Local Business?

Coding Liquids tutorial cover featuring Sagnik Bhattacharya for Performance Max vs AI Max: Which Suits a Local Business?
Coding Liquids tutorial cover featuring Sagnik Bhattacharya for Performance Max vs AI Max: Which Suits a Local Business?

Performance Max is a separate campaign type that serves your ads across Google Search, YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail and Maps. AI Max for Search is a set of features you switch on inside a normal Search campaign. For most local firms starting out, AI Max gives more control and clearer reporting; Performance Max suits firms with strong tracking and a bigger budget.

The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration

From formulas and pivot tables to Power Query, DAX, VBA and AI with Copilot, ChatGPT and Claude — hands-on from the first lesson.

By Sagnik Bhattacharya and Virginia Thorn, Primetime Emmy Award winner

Buy now

They are often mixed up because both use Google's automation and both can send people to pages you did not choose. The difference that matters for a small budget is where the automation sits: AI Max stays inside Search, with keywords and negative keywords you can still see. Performance Max is a broader system that you steer with assets and goals.

What are Performance Max and AI Max?

Performance Max is a separate campaign type that serves ads across all of Google's channels from one campaign, while AI Max for Search is a set of features inside a Search campaign. Google's help pages describe the two quite differently, and the wording tells you what to expect.

Performance Max in plain terms

One campaign, many places. Google says it provides access to all of Google's ad inventory, including YouTube, Display, Search, Discover, Gmail and Maps, from a single campaign. You do not build keyword lists as the core of it. You give it asset groups, which are collections of text, images, logos and video built around a theme, and a conversion goal such as leads or sales. Google's automation then combines the assets into ads and bids in real time. Controls exist, such as brand exclusions, negative keywords, search themes, placement exclusions and Final URL expansion, but the structure is designed to let the system decide where to show.

AI Max in plain terms

A bundle of features for Search campaigns, switched on with one click. Google's announcement groups them in three: expand reach (search term matching using broad match and keywordless technology), deliver relevant ads (text customisation and Final URL expansion) and controls and insights (locations of interest, brand controls, URL controls and reporting). Google's help page calls it an evolution of Dynamic Search Ads and of Performance Max with Final URL expansion. Because it lives inside Search, you keep the campaign structure, the keywords and the Search reporting you already know.

A word on defaults, since this trips people up. Google's help page says that turning on AI Max also turns on search term matching, text customisation and Final URL expansion. The Google Ads API documentation I read describes text customisation and Final URL expansion as opted out by default there. Interfaces differ and Google changes defaults, so after switching it on, open the settings and read each toggle before you trust any description, including mine.

How do control and reporting compare?

AI Max keeps the Search controls of keywords, negative keywords and a search terms report, while Performance Max is steered through asset groups, goals and exclusions, with reports by asset, asset group and channel. This table follows Google's own help pages at the time of writing; where a page did not cover something, I have said so.

PointPerformance MaxAI Max for Search
What it isA campaign typeA set of features inside a Search campaign
Where ads can showSearch, YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail and MapsSearch
What you supplyAsset groups, a conversion goal, optional targetYour existing Search campaign, keywords, ads, landing pages
Keyword roleSearch themes and keywordless targeting; not a keyword listYour keywords stay; keywordless matching extends them. Negative keywords are still respected
Brand controlsBrand exclusionsBrand inclusions at campaign and ad group level; brand exclusions at campaign level
Location extrasNot described on the page I readLocations of interest at ad group level, which Google says is exclusive to AI Max
URL controlsFinal URL expansion and related settingsURL inclusions per ad group, URL exclusions per campaign
Search term visibilityAsset, asset group and channel reports; the page did not name a search terms reportSearch terms report adds an AI Max match type and a source column; keywords, landing page and asset reports show AI Max contributions
BiddingSmart Bidding on conversion goalsAutomated bidding such as Maximize Conversions; search term matching does not work with Manual CPC
Test it safelyRun as a separate campaign and compare over weeksA one-click experiment can split traffic 50/50 against your base Search campaign

The row that decides it for me is search term visibility. A local firm pays for clicks, and the first question after a week is "what did people actually type?". AI Max answers that inside the report you already use. With a broader system, you often learn it in categories rather than line by line, and your control is mostly after the fact, through exclusions. If you are weighing how a specialist can help here, the tutorial on hiring a Google Ads specialist for Performance Max lists what to ask.

Which suits which kind of local firm?

A local firm should choose by how many enquiries it can track, how large the monthly budget is, and whether its sales are driven by searches or by being seen. Here is my rule of thumb, set out as a table. The thresholds are guidance for an illustration, not Google rules.

Your situationLean towardsWhy
Under about 20 tracked enquiries a month, small budgetA standard Search campaign, perhaps with AI Max in an experimentToo little data for Performance Max to learn; Search shows you the queries
You already run Search and want more reachAI Max on that campaign, tested against the originalKeeps your structure and lets you compare like with like
Strong conversion tracking, enough budget, wide service area, visual product (a venue, a caterer)Performance Max as a second campaignVideo, Display and Maps give you reach a Search-only campaign cannot
Sales depend on a few high-value jobsSearch, with AI Max only if you can review the search terms weeklyOne wasted click costs more; you need the visibility
You cannot yet tell a good lead from a bad one in the accountNeither yetFix tracking first; both features optimise towards whatever you tell Google counts

The last row is the most common. Both tools are optimisers: they find more of whatever your conversion goal rewards. If the goal is "any form fill", they will find form fills, including the wrong kind. The tutorial on Performance Max conversion tracking and what Smart Bidding needs first covers the groundwork, and it applies equally to AI Max.

A worked choice for an event venue

Here is an illustration with invented numbers. An event venue with one site spends $1,500 a month on Google Ads, all in a Search campaign with about 40 keywords. It records an enquiry form and a phone call as conversions and averages around 25 enquiries a month. Say the average enquiry converts to a booking one time in five, and a booking is worth $2,400.

  • 25 enquiries at $1,500 means $60 per enquiry.
  • One booking in five means 5 bookings, $12,000 of revenue, and $300 of ad spend per booking.

The owner wants more reach without wasting the budget. The options:

  1. Switch AI Max on for the whole campaign. Fast, but there is no comparison, so if results change you cannot tell whether AI Max or the season caused it.
  2. Create a Performance Max campaign with $500 of the budget. $500 on a campaign that needs conversion data to learn, with about 8 enquiries a month at best, is thin. Google's own guidance on this is that you should give a campaign time before judging it, and the series' six-week test plan makes the same point.
  3. Run AI Max as an experiment. Google's help page describes an experiment that splits the existing Search campaign into a control arm, with AI Max off, and a treatment arm, with it on. Text customisation, Final URL expansion and search term matching are on in the treatment arm by default, and you can switch search term matching off for individual ad groups there.

I would choose the third for the venue. The base campaign stays as the control, the experiment shows whether AI Max finds enquiries at a similar cost, and the search terms report shows what it matched. If the experiment's cost per enquiry stays near $60 and the extra queries look sensible, apply it. If cost jumps to $85 with odd searches, you have lost a few weeks of part-budget rather than the whole campaign. A Performance Max test can follow, as a separate decision, once the venue has more tracked data.

If you want to run cost-per-enquiry sums like these yourself, try The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration on Coding Liquids.

A second case: a translation agency with a narrow market

A translation agency selling certified document translation to a small set of language pairs has the opposite shape to the venue. Searches are specific ("certified translation of a marriage certificate into Spanish"), volumes are low and every lead is valuable. Say it spends $900 a month and gets 12 enquiries, $75 each. Here the risk with keywordless matching is relevance: a broad match on "translation" attracts free-tool searchers and students.

For this firm I would run AI Max in an experiment, but with search term matching switched on only in the ad groups for its core language pairs, and brand and URL controls set before the first day: exclude the careers and news pages as destinations, and keep Final URL expansion off until the pricing page is clear. Performance Max would wait. With 12 enquiries a month there is not enough conversion data for it to learn from, and its reach on YouTube and Display does little for someone who needs a certified document next week.

How do you turn AI Max on without surprises?

Before turning AI Max on, check the prerequisites on Google's help page, starting with budget and landing pages, because several are easy to skip.

  1. Budget. The page says AI Max will not be effective if the campaign is limited by budget, and shows an alert if it is. If your campaign already runs out of money by mid-day, raise the budget or narrow the targeting first.
  2. Landing pages. Final URL expansion can send people to pages you did not pick. Open your site's main pages and check that each one works as a destination: a clear heading, a form or phone number, no dead ends.
  3. Tracking templates. The page warns that incompatible tracking templates can cause 404 errors on expanded URLs. Test a few expanded URLs by hand.
  4. Existing broad match. If you turn off the broad match setting later, broad keywords no longer count as exact for prioritisation. If you care about that, add exact-match copies of those keywords.
  5. Pinning. If text customisation and Final URL expansion are both on, RSA pinning is not respected. If you must say the same legal wording in every ad, leave them off.
  6. URL and brand rules. Add URL exclusions for pages you never want shown, such as your careers page, and brand exclusions for competitors or terms you do not want to appear beside.

Then read the search terms report after a few days. Google says it adds "AI Max" as a match type for incremental terms and a column showing whether the match came from broad match expansion or keywordless matching. That label is what lets you judge the feature on its own terms.

How do you read AI Max rows in a search terms report?

Read AI Max rows by giving each search an action: keep, add as a keyword, add as a negative keyword, or watch. An illustrative extract, with made-up searches and figures, for a catering company's Search campaign after two weeks on AI Max:

Search termMatch typeClicksCostEnquiriesAction
office lunch cateringExact31$743Keep
buffet for 40 peopleAI Max12$292Add as a keyword; good find
catering jobsAI Max9$220Add as a negative keyword
wedding food ideasAI Max14$330Watch; likely research, may add a negative
food truck hireAI Max6$180Decide: a service you do not offer; negative

The reading: one new query worth promoting, three that are not yours. That is typical of a first fortnight and the reason to review weekly at the start. If most AI Max rows are junk, narrow it: turn off search term matching in the ad groups where it wanders, or turn off Final URL expansion. If most are close to your service, leave it alone and keep trimming negatives.

Here is a prompt you can use with an AI assistant to speed up the first review. Remove customer-identifying details first and paste only the search term, match type, cost and conversion columns.

Below is a Google Ads search terms report for a local catering company
that offers corporate lunches, buffets and weddings in one service area.
For each search term, say: relevant, borderline or irrelevant, and give
a one-line reason. Then list the terms I should add as negative keywords
(exact or phrase) and the terms worth adding as keywords. Do not invent
numbers. Ask me questions if a term is ambiguous.

[paste columns: search term, match type, clicks, cost, conversions]

The assistant's answer is a first pass. You overrule it when it calls a term irrelevant that you know converts, or relevant when it describes a service you stopped offering.

When does Performance Max earn its place for a local firm?

Performance Max is not the wrong choice for a local firm, just a different one, and it earns its place in three situations:

  • A visual business that people browse. A venue or caterer can show photographs and video across YouTube, Discover and Display, which a Search campaign cannot. If you have good images and a short video, the reach can be real.
  • Map presence. Maps is one of its channels, which matters if people find you by place.
  • Enough conversion data. If your account already records dozens of enquiries a month with a clean goal, the system has something to learn from.

It carries risks a Search campaign does not. Reporting is by asset and channel rather than a line-by-line search terms report, so you manage it through exclusions and signals. It works best with budget room and patience; the nine costly Performance Max mistakes for small businesses lists the ones I would avoid. If you are working out what budget it needs, Performance Max pricing and minimum budget shows how clicks are charged.

A local note I would add: Google has been moving Local Services Ads into Performance Max with pay-per-lead goals in phases from August 2026, per its help page. If you are a home-service business, read the Local Services Ads to Performance Max export checklist, because that change may decide the question for you.

What does a six-week plan to test AI Max look like?

A six-week test changes one thing at a time: confirm tracking and a baseline in week 0, run an even-split AI Max experiment from week 1, hold budgets and bids steady through weeks 2 to 3, compare results in week 4 and only then decide whether Performance Max is worth its own test.

  1. Week 0. Confirm conversion tracking records the right events, and write down your baseline: spend, enquiries, cost per enquiry, booked jobs.
  2. Week 1. Create the AI Max experiment with an even split between the two arms. Review the search terms report on day three and day seven and add negatives.
  3. Weeks 2 to 3. Do not change budgets or bids. Google's guidance for Performance Max is that frequent budget or bid edits restart learning, and the same discipline helps any test. Log any outside event: a promotion, a holiday, a competitor.
  4. Week 4. Compare cost per enquiry and, more usefully, enquiries that became jobs. If the experiment is not worse, apply it.
  5. Weeks 5 to 6. Decide whether a separate Performance Max campaign is worth testing with its own budget. If the answer is no, stop there.

The log does more than any setting. Note the date and the change in a sheet. When the numbers move, you want to know whether you did it, Google did it or the season did.

What should you avoid with AI Max and Performance Max?

Avoid judging after three days, counting every conversion equally, letting generated text say things you do not offer, and leaving the account unattended.

  • Judging after three days. Both systems need time, and weekday patterns matter for a business with weekend events.
  • Counting every conversion equally. A phone call of 5 seconds and a booked tasting are not the same event. Set minimum call lengths and use values if you can.
  • Letting generated text say things you do not offer. Text customisation is automated, and Google says you cannot control elements such as grammar or special offers. Read the asset report and remove anything wrong.
  • Leaving it unattended. A weekly ten-minute look at search terms, spend and enquiries beats a monthly panic.

If you would like to talk through which of these fits your firm, with your own numbers in front of us, that is a job for my AI implementation consultation. The Google pages change often, so check the current AI Max and Performance Max help pages before you act on any detail here. For the wider picture of whether AI can run the account at all, see can AI manage your Google Ads without an agency.

AI Max and Performance Max: questions owners ask

Is AI Max a replacement for Performance Max?

No. Google's help page describes AI Max for Search as an evolution of Dynamic Search Ads and of Performance Max with Final URL expansion, applied to Search campaigns. Performance Max remains its own campaign type serving Search, YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail and Maps from one campaign.

Can I run both at the same time?

Yes, as separate campaigns, but they can compete for the same searches and make results hard to read. For a small budget, test one for several weeks, then add the other in a controlled way. Record the dates of every change so you can tell what moved your numbers.

Does AI Max work without Smart Bidding?

Google's help page says AI Max relies on automated bidding such as Maximize Conversions, and that search term matching does not work with Manual CPC. Check your bid strategy before switching it on, and make sure conversion tracking is recording real enquiries first.

What should I check first if I turn on AI Max?

Check that the campaign is not budget-limited, that your landing pages work as dynamic destinations, and that tracking templates do not break them. Then read the search terms report within a week, looking for the AI Max match type and any searches you would not want.

Which gives me more control as a local business?

AI Max keeps you in a Search campaign with keywords, negative keywords and a search terms report that labels AI Max matches. Performance Max gives you asset groups and signals but less visibility into where spend goes. For most local firms starting out, Search with AI Max is the more controllable test.

Further reads

Show 2 more related tutorials

Sources: Google Ads Help pages on AI Max for Search campaigns and Performance Max campaigns, Google's announcement of AI Max, and Google Ads API documentation (checked 17 Nov 2026).

Have a specific process in mind?

Describe the job in your own words on a 1:1 call and I'll show you what AI you can use for it with the tools you already pay for.

Book a 1:1 call with me