For documenting a business process, Scribe suits repeatable click-by-click tasks that need editable written steps, while Loom suits judgement, tone and walkthroughs where the explanation matters more than the screens. A small business usually needs both: written steps for the routine, a short video for the reasoning. Scribe has a free plan; Loom's is limited.
The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration
From formulas and pivot tables to Power Query, DAX, VBA and AI with Copilot, ChatGPT and Claude — hands-on from the first lesson.
By Sagnik Bhattacharya and Virginia Thorn, Primetime Emmy Award winner
Buy nowThe choice follows the process, not the tool. A password reset is a list of steps; handling a difficult client is a conversation. Sort your processes first, then pay for the tool that matches each pile. The rest of this tutorial gives you a way to sort them, the costs for a six-person team, and a combined method that costs little extra.
What do Scribe and Loom each produce from the same task?
Scribe produces a page of numbered steps with a screenshot per click, while Loom produces a video of your screen and voice with a transcript.
Take one task: logging a new supplier in the accounts package. Record it once in each tool and the outputs differ in ways that matter later.
| Point of comparison | Scribe | Loom |
|---|---|---|
| What you get | A page of numbered steps with a screenshot per click, built as you work | A video of your screen and voice, with a transcript |
| How you edit it | Change the text of a step, delete or reorder steps, blur or annotate a screenshot (paid plans) | Trim the start and end; remove filler words and silences on the AI plan; re-record for bigger changes |
| Searchability | Every step is text, so a search for "supplier" finds it | The transcript is searchable, but you watch to find the moment |
| Time to read or watch | Skim in 30 seconds, follow as you go | Real time, though viewers can skip or speed up |
| Carries tone and reasoning | Only if you add notes | Naturally, in your voice |
| Needs narration | No | Yes, for AI features to work |
On Loom's side, the help centre says its AI Workflows feature turns a recording's transcript into a text document using templates that include SOP and step-by-step guide, and that it will not generate if the video has no speech. That is a different route from Scribe's. Loom's document comes from what you said; Scribe's comes from what you clicked. If you talk through a process badly, the Loom document inherits the mess. If you click through a process wrongly, the Scribe guide records the wrong clicks.
How much do Scribe and Loom cost for a six-person team?
On the vendors' November 2026 pages, six people pay $0 on the free plans, $78 to $102 a month for Scribe Pro Team, or $108 to $144 a month for Loom Business or Business + AI.
Prices below come from the vendors' pricing pages in November 2026. Scribe's page shows two prices per paid plan without saying which is monthly, so I give the range. Loom's page lists $18 and $24 per user a month, with annual billing said to save up to 17 percent.
| Setup (illustrative six-person bookkeeping practice) | Monthly cost | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Scribe Basic and Loom Starter, both free | $0 | Web capture in Scribe; Loom limited to 25 videos and 5-minute screen recordings at up to 720p |
| Scribe Pro Team, six seats | $78 to $102 | Desktop capture, redaction, branding, exports, comments |
| Loom Business, six users | $108 | Unlimited videos and recording time, up to 4K |
| Loom Business + AI, six users | $144 | Adds AI Workflows, auto titles, summaries, chapters, tasks, filler and silence removal |
| Scribe Pro Personal for two writers plus Loom Business + AI for two recorders | $50 to $70 plus $48 = $98 to $118 | Only the creators pay |
The last row is the one most small firms should use. Only the people who create guides and videos need paid seats; everyone else watches shared links. Check with each vendor that viewers do not need a paid seat before you rely on this. The Scribe plan breakdown goes through the seat rules, and the Loom AI plan analysis prices the extra $6 a user.
How do you decide whether a process needs written steps or video?
Score each process on a short list of questions: a fixed click path, a costly skipped step or a learner following along points to written steps; judgement or tone points to video.
Run each process on your list through four questions. Score a point for written if the answer is yes in the first column, and a point for video if yes in the second.
Question | Yes means written | Yes means video
-----------------------------------------------|-------------------|----------------
Is it the same click path every time? | written |
Does a wrong step cause damage if skipped? | written |
Does it need judgement, tone or "it depends"? | | video
Will the screens change within six months? | written (edit) |
Is the learner watching while doing the task? | written |
Is it a client or team walkthrough with talk? | | video
Here is that applied to six illustrative processes in a physiotherapy clinic.
| Process | Click path fixed? | Needs judgement? | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Booking a follow-up in the diary software | Yes | No | Written steps |
| Processing a card refund | Yes | Little, but errors cost money | Written steps |
| Explaining the cancellation policy to an upset patient | No | Yes | Video, plus a script |
| Setting up the treatment room at opening | Mostly physical | Some | Short video or photo checklist |
| Exporting the weekly utilisation report | Yes | No | Written steps |
| Onboarding a new clinician on the clinic's way of working | No | Yes | Video walkthrough, with a written checklist |
Three of six come out written, two video, and one mixed. That is typical: software tasks lean written, people tasks lean video. Photographs or a phone video fit physical rooms better than either tool.
When are written steps better than video?
Written steps beat video when the learner is following along, the task changes often, people search for answers, or you need an audit trail. Each of the four has a plain reason.
- The learner is doing the task as they read. A person with the accounts package on one half of the screen and a guide on the other can follow step 4 and look back to step 3 without scrubbing a timeline.
- The task changes often. If a supplier portal moves a button every quarter, fixing one line of a written guide takes a minute. A video of the old screen is wrong until someone re-records it.
- People search for answers. Staff type "how do I raise a credit note" into a wiki search and expect text. A video needs a transcript or a clear title to be found.
- You need an audit trail. Written steps with named owners and review dates are easier to show a client or an inspector than a library of recordings.
When is video better than written steps?
Video beats written steps when the point is how rather than what, when tone matters, when you need it done in ten minutes, or when a remote client needs a walkthrough.
- The point is how, not what. A senior bookkeeper explaining how to query an odd bank transaction conveys judgement a list of clicks cannot.
- Tone matters. How a receptionist should sound when a client is cross is learnt by hearing it.
- You need it done in ten minutes. Recording while you work and talking takes about as long as the task itself. Editing written steps from a capture takes a few minutes more.
- A remote client needs a walkthrough. A five-minute video explaining a proposal is warmer than a PDF.
The honest cost of video is upkeep. Loom's Starter plan caps screen recordings at five minutes and 25 videos, which suits short clips; if your library grows, you are in a paid plan, and a library of 60 clips with half out of date is worse than 20 current ones.
Can you use Scribe and Loom together for one process?
Yes: record once and produce both formats, either by adding a 90-second Loom clip to a Scribe capture or, on Loom's AI plan, by drafting a guide from a Loom transcript. You do not have to choose per process. Here are the two routes.
- Click-first. Capture the task in Scribe, then add a 90-second Loom clip at the top of the guide that explains when to use it and what goes wrong. Reader gets a quick why, then the steps.
- Talk-first. Record a Loom while explaining the task aloud. On the AI plan, use AI Workflows to produce a draft step-by-step guide from the transcript, then edit it. Loom's help centre says the feature needs a desktop browser and speech in the video, and that its availability depends on the AI plan, so check this on your account first. Read the draft against the video: transcripts of speech include "um, then you click the thing" that a draft can miss or invent.
The Loom AI Workflows tutorial walks through the talk-first route in detail, and the guide to SOPs from screen recordings shows how to polish the result with a general AI assistant.
A filled-in example: onboarding a new bookkeeper
A four-person bookkeeping practice wants a new starter productive in two weeks. The owner lists eight tasks and sorts them with the four questions.
| Task | Format | Owner | Review date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Set up a new client in the practice software | Scribe guide | Office manager | 6 months |
| Reconcile a bank feed | Scribe guide plus 2-minute Loom on odd items | Senior bookkeeper | 6 months |
| Chase a late client for records | Loom plus email template | Owner | 12 months |
| Month-end checklist | Written checklist | Senior bookkeeper | Each quarter |
| Issue an invoice and credit note | Scribe guide | Office manager | 6 months |
| Explain how the practice quotes | Loom walkthrough | Owner | 12 months |
| Back up and export client files | Scribe guide | Office manager | 6 months |
| Meeting a new client for the first time | Loom role-play clip | Owner | 12 months |
Count the result: four written guides, one checklist, three videos and one both. Creating all of it is a week of part-time effort for the two people involved, about two hours a day, which is the real investment; the subscriptions are small beside it.
How do you test whether your staff prefer written steps or video?
Test it with your own staff: give two colleagues two tasks in swapped formats and compare minutes, questions asked and mistakes. Claims about what staff prefer are cheap to repeat and rarely backed by evidence you can use. It takes under an hour.
- Pick one task new starters get wrong, such as raising a purchase order.
- Create it in both formats.
- Give a colleague who has never done it the written version and another colleague the video, alone, with a stopwatch.
- Record time to finish, questions asked, and mistakes found when you check the work.
- Swap formats with a second task and repeat.
Use a small results table:
Task: raise a purchase order | Format | Minutes | Questions asked | Errors
------------------------------------|---------|---------|-----------------|-------
Colleague A (written) | Scribe | 11 | 0 | 1
Colleague B (video) | Loom | 17 | 2 | 0
Task 2: issue a credit note | | | |
Colleague A (video) | Loom | 14 | 1 | 0
Colleague B (written) | Scribe | 9 | 0 | 0
The numbers above are illustrative, not findings. The point is the method: two tasks, two people, swapped, so one person's speed does not decide it. If the written version is consistently faster but has the odd error, add a warning line to the guide. If video leads to fewer errors, put a clip at the top of the written guide.
What mistakes make Scribe and Loom guides useless?
The common mistakes are recordings nobody can find, capturing a live client screen, and documenting a task that no one actually does.
A pattern I would watch for is the "recording nobody can find". A practice records 40 clips over a quarter, titles them "Recording 1" onwards, and drops them in a chat. Three months later nobody finds the one about credit notes. The fix is not a better tool; it is a naming rule and a single index page. Give every guide or clip a title that starts with the verb and the object, such as "Raise a purchase order", and keep one list with owner and review date.
The second mistake is capturing a live client screen. Whatever the tool, a screenshot or recording of real client data in a guide shared by link is a risk. Record against a demo client. Written guides can have details blurred on paid Scribe plans; a video with real names in it cannot be fixed without re-recording.
The third is documenting what no one does. Before capturing anything, ask three staff which tasks they asked about in the last month. Document those first.
A sample talk-first script that makes the AI draft better
If you go the talk-first route, the quality of the draft depends on how you speak. This is an illustrative opening for an IT support firm recording "add a new starter to the email system".
"This is how we add a new starter to email. It takes about five minutes.
You need three things first: their full name, their start date and
their manager's name from the HR form.
Step one: open the admin console and choose Users. Step two: choose
Add user. Type the full name exactly as on the form. Step three: set
the start date so the account switches on that morning. If you get a
message saying the name already exists, stop and tell the office manager.
That usually means a returning employee."
Spoken steps with numbers, named screens, a prerequisite list and a stop condition give an AI transcript-to-guide feature something to build on. Mumbling "so, press that, then this" gives it nothing. If you would rather decide with someone which processes to record first, my AI implementation consultation covers that; book a 1:1 call on the contact page.
An AI-drafted guide from a recording, with what to fix
To see what the talk-first route delivers, take the new-starter script above. A transcript-to-guide feature would return something like the illustrative draft below. This is not a recorded output from the product; it shows the kind of result and the fixes worth making.
DRAFT FROM THE TRANSCRIPT
Add a new starter to email (about 5 minutes)
Before you begin: full name, start date, manager's name (HR form).
1. Open the admin console and choose Users.
2. Choose Add user and type the full name as on the form.
3. Set the start date so the account switches on that morning.
4. If the name already exists, stop and tell the office manager.
FIXES A PERSON SHOULD MAKE
- Add the missing step: assign the licence and the mailbox size.
- Say why step 4 exists (returning employee, old mailbox may hold mail).
- Add a check at the end: send a test message to the new address.
- Add "Last reviewed: [date], owner: [name]".
Notice that the draft kept what was spoken and missed what was only shown. The speaker clicked a licence box on screen without saying so, and the transcript could not capture it. That gap is the main weakness of any transcript-based draft, and the reason a Scribe-style click capture is the safer first draft for software tasks.
A handover job: the wedding planner's venue day
Not every process happens on a screen. A wedding planner running events with two assistants needs a venue-day handover: where the suppliers load in, which door sticks, who holds the keys, what the florist needs by 9 am. Neither Scribe nor Loom is the first choice here, because the process is physical.
What works is a short phone video walking round the venue, with a written checklist next to it. A Loom recording made from a laptop or a phone clip uploaded to the shared folder both work; Loom's Starter plan allows 25 videos and five-minute screen recordings, so a one-minute video per venue fits within it for a while. Pair it with this filled-in checklist:
VENUE HANDOVER (example)
Venue: [name] Contact on the day: [first name], [phone]
Load-in: side gate, 8:00 am, van parking for two
Keys: held by the venue manager; collect at 8:15 am
Power: sockets behind the stage left curtain, 2 only
Known issues: fire door sticks, push firmly; no mobile signal in cellar
Supplier times: florist 9:00, caterer 10:30, band 3:00 pm
Photo / video link: [link]
The lesson is to keep the tool matched to the evidence. Where the process lives in a room, film the room. Where it lives in software, capture the software.
How many hours does upkeep cost for written guides versus video?
On illustrative figures, keeping 20 software guides current takes about 2 hours a year in writing and about 8 in video, so written steps are cheaper to maintain.
Subscriptions are the smaller bill. Upkeep is the larger, and it differs by format. Illustrative figures for a practice with 20 guides or clips:
| Item | Typical change per year | Written fix | Video fix | Annual hours (20 items) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software tasks | 2 screen changes each | 3 minutes to edit a step | 12 minutes to re-record | written 2 hours, video 8 hours |
| Policy explanations | 1 change each | 5 minutes to rewrite | 10 minutes to re-record | written 1.7 hours, video 3.3 hours |
On those assumptions a library of 20 software guides costs about 2 hours a year to keep current in writing and about 8 in video. At $30 an hour that is $60 against $240, a difference of $180 a year, which is more than one Pro Team seat at the lower price. The numbers are assumptions you should replace with your own; the direction, that written steps are cheaper to maintain for software that changes, holds up in practice.
An IT support firm choosing per task, with the reasoning
A six-person IT support firm sorts five common jobs. Printer driver install on a client's laptop: written steps, because the clicks never vary and a technician follows them at the client's desk. Explaining to a worried client why their backup failed: video, because tone and reassurance matter and the explanation changes each time. Setting up multi-factor sign-in for a new staff member: written steps with a short clip of the one confusing screen, since the phone-app part trips people up. Quarterly review call agenda: a checklist, as it is a list, not a skill. Handling a client who disputes an invoice: a short video of the senior partner, because it is mostly judgement. Five jobs, two written, one mixed, one checklist, one video. Nobody paid for a feature they did not use.
When to skip both tools
Three situations do not need either product. A process of three obvious steps needs a sentence in a shared note. A process done once a year by one person needs a checklist in a document, not a library. And a process that a manager is about to remove should not be documented at all. Spend the effort on the five or six tasks that cause the most questions, errors or delays, and use a free plan for the first month to find out which those are.
Keeping both libraries current
Whichever you choose, set a rhythm. Put a review date on each item and one person in charge of the index. Each quarter, open the index and check three guides at random against the live software. If two of the three are out of date, schedule a review of all of them. Written guides take minutes to correct; videos may need a re-record, which is a reason to keep them short, a few minutes each.
Finally, give guides a home people already visit. The comparison of AI knowledge base options covers where to store them so staff can search the lot at once.
If you keep your guide index, owners and review dates in a spreadsheet, The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration on Coding Liquids covers the spreadsheet side.
Scribe vs Loom for process documentation: questions owners ask
Can Loom's AI write a step-by-step guide like Scribe?
Partly. Loom's help centre says AI Workflows turn a recording's transcript into a text document using templates such as SOP and step-by-step guide, and it needs speech in the video. It builds from what you say, not from clicks. Scribe builds from your clicks and screens, so the two produce different drafts.
Which is cheaper for six people?
Scribe, on the vendors' November 2026 prices. Scribe Pro Team is shown at $13 to $17 per seat with a five-seat minimum, so six seats cost $78 to $102 a month. Loom Business is $18 a user, $108 for six, and Business + AI is $24, $144. Only creators need to pay on either, so the real bill is often lower.
Do staff prefer video or written steps?
There is no reliable general answer, so test with your own staff. A quick method is to give half the team a written guide and half a video for the same task, then time how long each takes to finish without asking questions. Repeat once with a different task.
Which is easier to keep up to date?
Written guides, usually. You can edit one step in text, while a changed screen in a video means re-recording or adding a patch clip. For fast-changing software, prefer steps you can edit in a minute, and keep any videos short so they are quick to redo.
Further reads
- How to Build a Company Knowledge Base AI Can Answer From — Building a knowledge base that staff and AI can both answer from.
- AI IT Documentation for MSPs: Client Runbooks From Screen Recordings — A recordings-to-runbooks method built for IT firms.
Browse all AI-for-business tutorials
Sources: Scribe pricing page (scribe.com/pricing) and Loom pricing page (loom.com/pricing), both checked November 2026; Loom help centre article on AI Workflows (support.loom.com), checked November 2026.
