Gemma 4 for Data Analysis: Can It Replace ChatGPT for Spreadsheet Work?

Coding Liquids tutorial cover featuring Sagnik Bhattacharya for Gemma 4 vs ChatGPT for Data Analysis and Spreadsheet Work, with AI model comparison visuals and Excel grids.
Coding Liquids tutorial cover featuring Sagnik Bhattacharya for Gemma 4 vs ChatGPT for Data Analysis and Spreadsheet Work, with AI model comparison visuals and Excel grids.

Yes, Gemma 4 can replace ChatGPT for many routine spreadsheet tasks, such as writing formulas, cleaning data and drafting simple VBA, and it runs free on your own machine. It gave useful answers in all five spreadsheet tests below, but ChatGPT is still the better choice when you want to upload a file and have the AI run code on it.

The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration

From formulas and pivot tables to Power Query, DAX, VBA and AI with Copilot, ChatGPT and Claude — hands-on from the first lesson.

By Sagnik Bhattacharya and Virginia Thorn, Primetime Emmy Award winner

Buy now

I have spent the past two weeks putting Gemma 4 through a structured set of real spreadsheet challenges — the same kinds of tasks I teach in my Excel course. Not synthetic benchmarks, but actual messy data, actual broken formulas, and actual VBA requirements from real projects. Here is what I found.

How was Gemma 4 tested?

Gemma 4 was tested on five realistic spreadsheet scenarios, each scored on accuracy, explanation quality and edge-case handling.

I ran Gemma 4 (31B parameter version) locally through Ollama on my machine. I used five spreadsheet scenarios of the kind I teach in The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration, so the tasks reflect genuine business use cases rather than contrived examples.

Each test was scored on three criteria: accuracy of the output (did the formula or code actually work?), quality of the explanation (did it help the user understand what was happening?), and handling of edge cases (did it account for blanks, errors, or unusual data?). Let me walk through each one.

Test 1: Data Cleaning — Messy CSV With Inconsistent Dates and Mixed Formats

The scenario: a 2,000-row CSV export from a legacy CRM system. Dates appeared in at least four formats — dd/mm/yyyy, mm-dd-yyyy, yyyy.mm.dd, and plain text like "15 March 2025". Phone numbers mixed country codes with local formats. Product names had random capitalisation and trailing spaces. This is exactly the kind of messy file real businesses work with every day.

I gave Gemma 4 this prompt: "I have a CSV with a Date column that mixes dd/mm/yyyy, mm-dd-yyyy, yyyy.mm.dd, and written dates like '15 March 2025'. I need a single formula approach to normalise everything to dd/mm/yyyy in Excel. Also suggest a strategy for cleaning phone numbers that mix +91-XXXXXXXXXX with 0XX-XXXXXXXX formats and product names with inconsistent capitalisation."

Gemma 4's response was solid. It suggested a nested approach using DATEVALUE combined with TEXT and SUBSTITUTE, and correctly identified that written dates like "15 March 2025" would need a separate handling path. It recommended a helper column strategy — parse each format with IFERROR wrappers and combine them. For phone numbers, it suggested SUBSTITUTE chains to remove hyphens and spaces, then RIGHT to extract the last 10 digits. For product names, it correctly recommended PROPER(TRIM()).

Verdict: Gemma 4's approach was functional and correct — it would work in production. If you are already comfortable with data cleaning strategies, Gemma 4 gives you enough to work with.

Test 2: Pivot Table Logic — Designing and Building Pivot Table Formulas

The scenario: a sales dataset with columns for Region, Salesperson, Product Category, Quarter, and Revenue. The task was to ask Gemma 4 to suggest an appropriate pivot table structure and then provide the equivalent formulas for users who need a formula-based approach (common when the data source updates frequently and you want formulas that recalculate automatically).

I prompted Gemma 4: "I have a sales table with Region (North/South/East/West), Salesperson (names), Product Category (Electronics/Furniture/Software), Quarter (Q1-Q4), and Revenue. Suggest a pivot table layout to analyse revenue by region and category, then give me the SUMIFS formulas to replicate this as a formula-based summary table."

Gemma 4 suggested a clean two-dimensional layout with regions as rows and categories as columns, which is exactly what most analysts would want. The SUMIFS formulas it generated were correct, with proper absolute and relative references. It also suggested adding a Grand Total row and column using SUM.

Verdict: Gemma 4's core answer was accurate and usable — the SUMIFS formulas worked perfectly. For building the pivot table itself, see my guide to mastering pivot tables.

Test 3: VBA Macro Generation — Multi-Sheet Consolidation

The task: write a VBA macro that loops through all worksheets in a workbook (except a "Summary" sheet), copies data from a consistent range (A2 to the last row in column D) on each sheet, and pastes it sequentially onto the Summary sheet with a source sheet name column added.

Gemma 4 produced a working macro. It correctly used For Each ws In ThisWorkbook.Worksheets, included the If ws.Name <> "Summary" check, found the last row using Cells(Rows.Count, 1).End(xlUp).Row, and appended data to the Summary sheet. The source sheet name was added in column E. The code ran without errors on my test workbook.

Verdict: Gemma 4's macro worked, which is genuinely impressive for a free local model, though its structure was basic. For anyone learning VBA through AI-assisted macro generation, it is a useful starting point.

Test 4: Chart and Visualisation Recommendations

I described a dataset to Gemma 4: monthly revenue and customer count for four product lines over two years, with a goal of presenting trends to a non-technical executive audience. I asked it what chart types to use and how to structure the visualisation.

Gemma 4 recommended a line chart for revenue trends over time (one line per product), a clustered bar chart for comparing product lines by quarter, and a combo chart (line + bar) to show revenue against customer count on dual axes. Solid, conventional recommendations.

Verdict: If you are already experienced with charts and visualisations, Gemma 4's solid, conventional recommendations are perfectly adequate.

The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration

From formulas and pivot tables to Power Query, DAX, VBA and AI with Copilot, ChatGPT and Claude — hands-on from the first lesson.

By Sagnik Bhattacharya and Virginia Thorn, Primetime Emmy Award winner

Buy now

Test 5: Formula Debugging — Diagnosing a Broken Formula

I pasted this deliberately broken formula into Gemma 4 and asked it to identify and fix all the issues:

=IFERROR(VLOOKUP(A2,Sheet2!B:F,5,TRUE),"Not Found")+IF(C2>"100",D2*0.1,D2*0.05)

There are multiple problems here: the VLOOKUP match type should probably be FALSE for an exact match; the IF condition compares C2 to the text string "100" instead of the number 100; and the IFERROR wraps only the VLOOKUP but the entire expression can still error if the IF part fails.

Gemma 4 caught two of the three issues. It correctly identified the TRUE/FALSE match type problem and the text-vs-number comparison in the IF statement. It missed the incomplete IFERROR coverage.

Verdict: Formula debugging requires the model to reason about multiple interacting parts of an expression, and this was Gemma 4's weakest test. Even so, catching two out of three issues is still genuinely useful — for many users, those two fixes alone would have resolved their problem. For more complex formula debugging, see my guide on advanced Excel formulas.

How did Gemma 4 do overall?

Gemma 4 gave accurate, usable answers in four of the five spreadsheet tests and caught two of three bugs in the fifth, and it runs locally for free.

Task Gemma 4 Notes
Data cleaning (messy CSV) Good — functional formulas, correct approach Gemma 4 workable for experienced users
Pivot table logic Good — accurate SUMIFS, clean layout SUMIFS formulas worked perfectly
VBA macro generation Good — working macro, basic structure Gemma 4 output runs correctly as-is
Chart recommendations Good — solid standard recommendations Gemma 4 sufficient for experienced analysts
Formula debugging Adequate — caught 2 of 3 issues Missed the incomplete IFERROR coverage
Privacy and data control Excellent — fully local, no data leaves your machine Critical for sensitive business data
Cost Free No subscription, no usage caps
Speed (after initial load) Fast on GPU, slower on CPU Depends on local hardware

When is Gemma 4 the better choice for spreadsheet AI?

Gemma 4 is the better choice for sensitive data, high-volume routine tasks, offline work, tight budgets and learning, because it runs locally with no cost per query.

There are clear scenarios where Gemma 4 is the smarter choice:

  • Sensitive data — If you are working with financial records, employee data, client information, or anything governed by data protection policies, Gemma 4 running locally means your data never leaves your machine. This is not a minor advantage — it is often a hard requirement in enterprise settings.
  • High-volume routine tasks — If you need to generate 50 similar formulas in a session, Gemma 4 has no usage caps, while ChatGPT's free plan limits messages with file uploads and slows down at busy times.
  • Offline work — Gemma 4 works without an internet connection. If you travel, work on secure networks, or simply have unreliable connectivity, it is always available.
  • Budget-conscious teams — For a team of 10 analysts, ChatGPT Plus would cost $200/month. Gemma 4 costs nothing after the initial hardware investment. Over a year, that is $2,400 saved.
  • Learning and experimentation — When you are exploring prompts and iterating rapidly, having no cost per query encourages experimentation. Students in my courses often learn faster when they are not worried about burning through API credits.

If you want to get started with running Gemma 4 on your own machine, I have written a complete beginner's guide to running Gemma 4 locally that walks through the entire setup process.

If you want help choosing between local and cloud AI for your own spreadsheets, I offer a one-to-one AI consultation.

When should you use ChatGPT instead of Gemma 4?

Use ChatGPT instead of Gemma 4 when you want to upload a spreadsheet file and have the AI run code on it, which Gemma 4 in Ollama cannot do.

ChatGPT can directly ingest your spreadsheet file, run Python code on it, and return results. Gemma 4 running through Ollama can read a text, PDF or image file you drop into the Ollama app, but it cannot run code on your spreadsheet the way Code Interpreter does. This is a significant workflow difference for data analysis.

ChatGPT also runs on OpenAI's servers, so it does not depend on your own hardware the way Gemma 4 does: Gemma 4 is fast on a GPU but slower on a CPU.

For a broader comparison that includes Claude and other models, see my detailed AI model comparison for 2026.

If you want to learn the Excel skills that make AI-written formulas easier to check, try The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration on Coding Liquids.

Which should you use for spreadsheet work?

Use Gemma 4 for routine tasks and sensitive data, and switch to ChatGPT when you need it to analyse an uploaded spreadsheet file.

After running these tests and using both models extensively, here is my practical advice:

  1. Start with Gemma 4 for routine tasks. Formula writing, basic data cleaning logic, simple VBA — Gemma 4 handles these well and costs nothing. Install it through Ollama and keep it running in the background.
  2. Switch to ChatGPT for file analysis. When you need the AI to read your spreadsheet file and run code on it, switch to ChatGPT. Its free plan limits messages with file uploads, so Plus is worth it if you do this daily.
  3. Use both for learning. Ask Gemma 4 for a formula, then ask ChatGPT the same question. Compare the approaches. This is one of the most effective learning strategies I recommend to my students.
  4. Default to Gemma 4 for sensitive data. If you are unsure whether your data should go to a cloud service, the answer is to use the local model. You can always re-prompt ChatGPT with anonymised or sample data if you need its extra capability.

For a head-to-head comparison of how Gemma 4 handles Excel formulas specifically versus Llama 4, see my detailed formula comparison test. And if you want practical prompts to use with either model, my collection of 60 AI prompts for Excel works well with both Gemma 4 and ChatGPT.

The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration

From formulas and pivot tables to Power Query, DAX, VBA and AI with Copilot, ChatGPT and Claude — hands-on from the first lesson.

By Sagnik Bhattacharya and Virginia Thorn, Primetime Emmy Award winner

Buy now

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Gemma 4 actually replace ChatGPT for Excel and spreadsheet work?

Yes, for many common spreadsheet tasks: in the tests here Gemma 4 handled formula writing, data cleaning logic and a basic VBA macro well, and it runs completely free on your own machine. It cannot take an uploaded spreadsheet and run code on it the way ChatGPT with Code Interpreter can, so use Gemma 4 for routine spreadsheet AI tasks and switch to ChatGPT when you need file analysis.

Which Gemma 4 model size should I use for Excel and data analysis tasks?

Use the 12B parameter version of Gemma 4 for spreadsheet formula generation and data cleaning prompts: running through Ollama, it is a good balance of speed and quality. If you have a GPU with 16GB or more VRAM, the 26B A4B or 31B version will give noticeably better results on complex analytical tasks like pivot table design and VBA macro generation. The smaller E4B version works for simple formula lookups but struggles with multi-step reasoning.

Is my spreadsheet data safe when using Gemma 4 for analysis?

Yes — this is one of Gemma 4's strongest advantages. Because Gemma 4 runs entirely on your local machine through tools like Ollama, your data never leaves your computer. Nothing is sent to external servers. This makes it ideal for sensitive financial data, proprietary business information, or any spreadsheet work where data privacy is a concern. With ChatGPT, your prompts are processed on OpenAI's servers, which may not be acceptable under certain compliance frameworks.

How do I get Gemma 4 to understand my specific spreadsheet layout?

Give Gemma 4 clear context in your prompt. Describe your column headers, the type of data in each column, and what row your data starts on. For example: "I have a spreadsheet with columns A (Date, dd/mm/yyyy format), B (Product Name, text), C (Quantity, integer), D (Unit Price, decimal). Data starts at row 2. Headers are in row 1." This level of detail helps Gemma 4 generate accurate formulas and references, just as it would with any cloud-based AI model.

Can Gemma 4 do data analysis like ChatGPT?

Not fully. Gemma 4 can help with data analysis by writing formulas, explaining patterns and suggesting analysis approaches, but it cannot run code on your spreadsheet the way ChatGPT with Code Interpreter can. You describe your data or paste it as text. For formula-based analysis guidance, Gemma 4 is surprisingly capable for a free local model.

Is Gemma 4 accurate for spreadsheet work?

Yes, for most standard spreadsheet tasks, including VLOOKUP, XLOOKUP, SUMIFS, pivot table guidance and data cleaning formulas. It occasionally makes errors on very complex nested formulas with multiple criteria, and in the debugging test here it caught two of three issues, but for everyday Excel work Gemma 4 is accurate enough to be useful.

Related tutorials

Sources