A virtual receptionist costs about $1.50 to $2.13 a call on Smith.ai's AI plans and about $0.50 to $1.50 on Rosie, against about $9 to $11 for Smith.ai's human receptionists and roughly $7 to $17 on Ruby, at 50 to 200 calls a month. Ruby's figure depends on call length. These are normalised from list prices, not quotes.
The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration
From formulas and pivot tables to Power Query, DAX, VBA and AI with Copilot, ChatGPT and Claude — hands-on from the first lesson.
By Sagnik Bhattacharya and Virginia Thorn, Primetime Emmy Award winner
Buy nowNo two of these vendors count the same thing. Ruby sells receptionist minutes, Smith.ai sells calls, and Rosie sells minutes of AI conversation. To compare them you have to convert everything into cost per call, which needs an assumption about how long a call lasts. The tables below show the working, so you can replace my assumptions with your own.
How does each virtual receptionist vendor measure what you buy?
Ruby sells receptionist minutes, Smith.ai sells calls on its human and AI plans, and Rosie sells minutes of AI conversation, so you need one common unit to compare them.
- Ruby: plans of 50, 100, 200 and 500 receptionist minutes a month. The page does not say how a minute is counted, or what overage costs.
- Smith.ai human receptionists: plans of 30, 90 and 300 calls a month, billed per client call, not per minute. Wrong numbers and spam do not count if forwarded lines pass caller ID.
- Smith.ai AI receptionist: a free plan for 25 calls and Pro and Enterprise plans from 75 to 1,000 calls. Every call the AI answers counts by default.
- Rosie: AI-only plans of 250, 1,000 and 2,000 minutes a month. Its pricing FAQ, checked on 20 November 2026, says there is no per-minute overage: going over moves you up to the next plan at that plan's standard price, its terms keep the higher plan for that billing period and at least the next two before you can move back down, and Growth users who regularly pass 2,000 minutes get a custom-volume plan.
What are the list prices for Ruby, Smith.ai and Rosie?
Ruby plans run from $250 for 50 minutes to $1,725 for 500 minutes, Smith.ai human plans from $300 for 30 calls to $2,100 for 300 calls, and Rosie plans from $49 to $299 a month.
| Service | Plan | Monthly price | Included | Overage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ruby | Plan 1 | $250 | 50 minutes | Not published |
| Ruby | Plan 2 | $395 | 100 minutes | Not published |
| Ruby | Plan 3 | $720 | 200 minutes | Not published |
| Ruby | Plan 4 | $1,725 | 500 minutes | Not published |
| Smith.ai human | Starter | $300 | 30 calls | $11.50 a call |
| Smith.ai human | Basic | $810 | 90 calls | $10.50 a call |
| Smith.ai human | Pro | $2,100 | 300 calls | $8.50 a call |
| Smith.ai AI | Free | $0 | 25 calls | $3.00 a call |
| Smith.ai AI | Pro, three tiers | $150 / $270 / $500 | 75 / 150 / 300 calls | $2.50 / $2.30 / $2.17 a call |
| Rosie | Professional | $49 | 250 minutes | None per minute; moves you up to Scale at $149 |
| Rosie | Scale | $149 | 1,000 minutes | None per minute; moves you up to Growth at $299 |
| Rosie | Growth | $299 | 2,000 minutes | None per minute; custom-volume plan if you regularly go over |
One more wrinkle: Smith.ai's pricing page and its AI-receptionist page each show a plan called "Pro", with different numbers. The $2,100 Pro is the human plan; the $150 to $500 Pro is the AI plan. Make sure a quote says which one you are buying.
What does Smith.ai cost per call at 50, 100 and 200 calls?
Smith.ai's AI plans come to about $1.50, $2.13 and $1.93 a call at 50, 100 and 200 calls a month, against about $10.60, $9.15 and $9.83 on its human plans. Smith.ai is the easiest to normalise, because it bills calls. For each volume, I picked the cheapest combination of plan and overage from the prices above.
| Calls a month | Human: cheapest route | Human total | Per call | AI: cheapest route | AI total | Per call |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 | Starter $300 plus 20 x $11.50 | $530 | $10.60 | Free: 25 free plus 25 x $3 | $75 | $1.50 |
| 100 | Basic $810 plus 10 x $10.50 | $915 | $9.15 | Pro 75-call tier $150 plus 25 x $2.50 | $212.50 | $2.13 |
| 200 | Basic $810 plus 110 x $10.50 | $1,965 | $9.83 | Pro 150-call tier $270 plus 50 x $2.30 | $385 | $1.93 |
Two things stand out. The human plans cost about five times the AI plans per call at every volume. And the cheapest route changes with volume: at 50 calls the free AI plan beats Pro, but past about 60 calls the Pro plan wins, because $3 overage costs more than the Pro base. Smith.ai's human add-ons also matter: appointment booking and call recording are priced as extras on its human plans (check the current add-on rates on its pricing page), so a booking-heavy business may pay a premium on every call.
What does Ruby cost per call, and why does call length matter?
Ruby costs roughly $7 to $17 a call, because it bills receptionist minutes and call length decides the figure. A per-call figure therefore needs a call length, so I use two illustrative lengths, two minutes and three minutes, and choose the smallest plan that covers the minutes. Because Ruby does not publish overage, I move to the next plan up instead of guessing it. If Ruby quotes you an overage rate, the true cost may be lower.
| Calls a month | At 2 minutes a call | Per call | At 3 minutes a call | Per call |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 | 100 minutes: Plan 2, $395 | $7.90 | 150 minutes: Plan 3, $720 | $14.40 |
| 100 | 200 minutes: Plan 3, $720 | $7.20 | 300 minutes: Plan 4, $1,725 | $17.25 |
| 200 | 400 minutes: Plan 4, $1,725 | $8.63 | 600 minutes: above Plan 4 | quote needed |
The pattern is that Ruby is good value when calls are short and plans are well filled, and poor value when calls are long or volume sits just above a plan's limit. A plan sized to your average is also exposed to a busy month. If you want to estimate your own minutes, Ruby receptionist cost: estimate minutes from one week of calls shows how.
What does Rosie cost per call?
Rosie costs about $0.49 to $1.49 a call at the same two- and three-minute call lengths, because its AI is billed in minutes of AI conversation, which are cheap.
| Calls a month | At 2 minutes | Plan and price | Per call | At 3 minutes | Plan and price | Per call |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 | 100 minutes | Professional $49 | $0.98 | 150 minutes | Professional $49 | $0.98 |
| 100 | 200 minutes | Professional $49 | $0.49 | 300 minutes | Scale $149 | $1.49 |
| 200 | 400 minutes | Scale $149 | $0.75 | 600 minutes | Scale $149 | $0.75 |
Rosie's Professional plan includes spam detection, appointment links by text and a website chat widget, but the page says calendar booking and live call transfers start on Scale. If you need the AI to put appointments in a calendar or hand a call to a person, price Scale at $149, not Professional at $49. There is no per-minute overage, but going past the minutes moves you up to the next plan at its standard price, so the cheapest plan is cheapest only while you stay inside its minutes.
Which virtual receptionist is cheapest per call?
Rosie and Smith.ai's AI plans are the cheapest per call, at about $0.49 to $2.13, while Ruby and Smith.ai's human plans cost about $7.20 to $17.25.
| Per call | 50 calls | 100 calls | 200 calls |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rosie (AI, 2-3 minute calls) | $0.98 | $0.49 to $1.49 | $0.75 |
| Smith.ai AI | $1.50 | $2.13 | $1.93 |
| Ruby (human, 2-minute calls) | $7.90 | $7.20 | $8.63 |
| Ruby (human, 3-minute calls) | $14.40 | $17.25 | quote needed |
| Smith.ai human | $10.60 | $9.15 | $9.83 |
This is a price comparison, not a quality comparison. A human receptionist who calms a worried caller and takes a detailed message is a different product from an AI that answers routine questions and logs a message. The cheaper services are cheaper because they do less of that, and the question is whether the calls you get need it.
If you want to build this per-call comparison in a spreadsheet of your own, try The Complete Excel Course with AI Integration on Coding Liquids.
A worked example: an insurance broker with 100 calls a month
Take an insurance broker with three advisers who gets about 100 calls a month, of which roughly 60 are routine (opening hours, document requests, where to send a certificate) and 40 are people who want to talk about a claim or a renewal. This is an illustration with assumed splits.
- All human on Smith.ai: $915 a month, as above.
- All AI on Smith.ai: $212.50, with the 40 sensitive calls handed to an adviser by the AI.
- A split: the 60 routine calls on Smith.ai's free AI plan (25 free plus 35 x $3 = $105, against $150 for the Pro 75-call tier), and the 40 sensitive calls straight to the advisers' mobiles with no service. Cost: about $105.
- Rosie at 2 minutes: $49 for 200 minutes, or $149 on Scale if the AI must book into a calendar.
If missing a sensitive call costs a client, the human plan buys peace of mind: $915 against $212.50 is about $700 a month, or roughly $17 for each of the 40 sensitive calls if only those need a person. The sensible middle, for many firms, is AI for the routine calls with a reliable handover for the rest. How to design that handover is covered in AI receptionist or answering service for a booking-based business.
Three firms, three different answers
An accountancy practice at 50 calls a month
Mostly existing clients asking for a document or an appointment, plus a few new enquiries. At 50 calls the numbers are $75 on Smith.ai's free AI plan, $49 on Rosie, and $395 or more on Ruby. The practice's real risk is the new-client call, because a first impression is expensive to repair. A reasonable answer is AI for the routine calls and a message-taking rule that sends new enquiries straight to a partner's phone, with a note of the caller's number so nobody has to call back blind.
A law firm with four fee earners at 200 calls a month
Calls are longer, often tearful or urgent, and confidentiality is a concern. At 200 calls, Smith.ai human is $1,965 and Ruby at two minutes a call is $1,725, with three minutes pushing past Ruby's largest plan. The AI options are $385 and $149 on the same volume, but a firm that takes urgent family or criminal calls will likely want a person on the line. A split is common: human receptionists for the main number and AI for the after-hours line, which can lower the bill, by an amount that depends on how many calls arrive after hours.
An architecture practice at 100 calls a month
Most calls are suppliers, clients checking progress and a few new project enquiries. Many callers are happy to leave a message. Rosie at $49 to $149, or Smith.ai AI at about $212.50, covers it, and the practice can send a text summary to the director. A human service would be paying roughly $7 to $17 a call to take messages the AI takes for a fraction of that.
What should you give an AI receptionist so it answers properly?
An AI receptionist answers properly when you give it a short briefing: facts it may state, what it must never say, what to take from every caller and which words trigger a transfer. Cost is only worth comparing once the service answers well, and a short, concrete briefing beats a long vague one. Here is a filled-in example for the broker.
BUSINESS: independent insurance broker, three advisers, open 9 to 5:30 weekdays.
ANSWER FROM FACTS ONLY: opening hours; "send documents to the shared inbox";
renewals are handled by the adviser named on the policy.
NEVER: say whether something is covered; give prices; promise call-backs by a time.
ALWAYS TAKE: name, number, policy number if known, reason, best time to call.
URGENT WORDS (transfer to [adviser mobile]): "claim", "accident", "flood", "fire".
IF UNSURE: take a message and say an adviser will call back.
The "never" list does the most work. An AI that confidently says a flood is covered, when your policy wording says otherwise, costs far more than any receptionist fee. Keep the facts it may state short, check them every quarter, and test the urgent-word rule with a call that uses a different word, such as "burst pipe", to see whether it still transfers.
A realistic problem: the message that said nothing
Imagine a message summary that reads: "Caller wants to talk about their policy. Call back." The name is there, the number is there, and the reason is empty. The cause is usually a briefing that asked the AI to take a message without saying what a useful message contains. The fix is the "always take" line above, plus listening to ten recordings in the first week and rewriting the briefing wherever a message was thin. This is also where a human service earns some of its price, because a trained receptionist asks the follow-up question without being told to.
A quick sum: what a missed call costs
The fee should be set against what you lose when nobody answers. Suppose the architecture practice misses 20 calls a month, of which 3 would have been new enquiries, and one new enquiry in four turns into a project worth a $4,000 fee. Three enquiries a month at a one-in-four conversion is 0.75 projects, worth about $3,000 a month in fees. Against that, an AI service at $149 is trivial. If instead the practice misses 20 calls and none is a new enquiry, the same fee buys little. Count your own missed calls and sort them before you decide that any of these services is worth it. For a structured way to measure the return after you start, see how to measure an AI receptionist's return in the first 90 days.
What are the contract terms and small print for each service?
Ruby says no long-term contracts, Smith.ai is month-to-month and Rosie says you can cancel anytime, but the three differ on trials, refunds, annual billing and how plan changes are billed.
| Term | Ruby | Smith.ai | Rosie |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contract length | "No long-term contracts" | Month-to-month | "Cancel anytime" |
| Cancellation | Not described on pages I read | Human: billed to end of cycle. AI: 30 days' notice | No contracts or cancellation fees; cancel in the admin and keep access to the end of the billing period |
| Trial or guarantee | None mentioned | 30-day money-back on human plans, up to $1,000, overage not refunded | 7-day free trial |
| Annual billing | Not shown | 10% off a 12-month human subscription; AI annual not stated | Described as two months free; prices not listed |
| Setup fees | None for activation or onboarding | None | Not stated |
| Changing plan | Not described | Anytime by email; billed from the next month | In the admin: upgrades at once, downgrades from the next billing cycle, but its terms keep an upgrade for that billing period and at least the next two; going over the $49 or $149 plan's minutes moves you up automatically (checked 20 November 2026) |
Smith.ai's own pages disagree on the refund window: the main text says 30 days and one FAQ answer says the first two weeks. Ask which applies. For Ruby, ask in writing how a plan change is billed. For Ruby and Rosie, ask whether unused minutes roll over, because neither page says; Rosie's cancellation and plan-change terms above are from its pricing FAQ, checked on 20 November 2026.
Which questions move a virtual receptionist bill the most?
Three questions move the bill most: what counts as a call or a minute, what happens when you reach the plan limit, and whether the service can hand a call to a person.
What counts as a call or a minute
Smith.ai's AI plans count every call the AI answers, so a caller who rings twice counts twice, and so does a salesperson. Its page lets you remove up to 10% of calls from the bill for selected spam, which is worth using. On Ruby, the unpublished minute definition could include time spent transferring or leaving a message, so ask.
What happens at the limit
Ruby publishes no overage, so ask what happens at minute 51 on a 50-minute plan, in writing. A good answer names a per-minute rate, or the exact plan you would be moved to and how you move back; a bad one is a vague "we would upgrade you". Rosie gives the second kind of answer on its pricing page: no per-minute overage, an automatic move up to the next plan at that plan's standard price, and its terms keep you there for that billing period and at least the next two before you can move back down. On the $49 plan, a month that runs a few minutes past 250 can therefore cost up to $149, and so can the two months after it.
What is handed over to a person
Both human and AI services can take messages. What differs is whether they can transfer a live call, book into your calendar or send a text, and on which plan. Rosie lists live and warm transfers from Scale. Smith.ai's human plans include a set number of free transfer destinations, and extra ones may cost more. These extras move the per-call figure.
How do you work out your own virtual receptionist cost in one afternoon?
Pull a month of call logs, time twenty real calls, sort the calls into routine, booking and sensitive, then price each group against the matching rows.
- Pull a month of call logs from your phone provider and count calls, excluding spam and wrong numbers.
- Time twenty real calls from start to finish to get your average length; do not guess.
- Sort the calls into routine, booking, and sensitive. Count each group.
- Price the routine and booking groups against the AI rows, and the sensitive group against the human rows.
- Add the extras you need: transfers, recording, booking, a calendar link.
- Ask each vendor for the overage and plan-change terms in writing.
Calls last month (excluding spam/wrong number): [ 112 ]
Average length of 20 timed calls: [ 2.4 min ]
Routine: [ 61 ] Booking: [ 22 ] Sensitive: [ 29 ]
Minutes needed: 112 x 2.4 = 269 min
Rosie fit: 269 min > 250 -> Scale ($149); over 250, Rosie moves you up anyway
Smith.ai AI fit: Pro 75-call tier $150 + 37 x $2.50 = $242.50 -> $2.17 a call
Ruby fit: 269 min -> Plan 4 $1,725 (or Plan 3 + overage: ask)
Chosen: AI for routine + booking; sensitive to adviser mobile
Review in: 60 days
That sheet is an invented example showing the method. The point of the review date is to compare the real bill with the estimate, because call mixes drift.
What I would not do
I would not buy the biggest plan on the strength of a busy week, and I would not pick on the rate card alone. I would start on the free or lowest tier of an AI service for a month, test it on real calls, and listen to every recording in the first week. A receptionist, human or AI, speaks for your business. If a service cannot say what it does when it does not know the answer, it is not ready to answer your phone.
For a Smith.ai-specific view, see Smith.ai pricing for 50, 150 and 300 calls a month, and Rosie AI pricing for the minute plans. If you would rather work it out against your own call log, that is what my AI implementation consultation covers.
Virtual receptionist pricing: the awkward questions
Why is Ruby so much dearer per call than Smith.ai AI or Rosie?
Ruby's plans are staffed by human receptionists and billed in minutes, so a long call costs more. Smith.ai's AI plans and Rosie use AI to answer, which costs far less per call. The right comparison is what each does for the calls that matter to you, not the rate card alone.
What counts as a call at Smith.ai?
Smith.ai bills per client call rather than per minute. Its human plans exclude wrong numbers and spam if forwarded lines pass caller ID; its AI plans count every call the AI answers by default, filter known spam and let you remove up to 10% of calls from the bill for selected spam.
Does Rosie publish overage rates?
It has no per-minute overage to publish. When checked on 20 November 2026, Rosie's pricing FAQ said that after warning emails, going over your 250 or 1,000 minutes moves you up to the next plan at that plan's standard price, and its terms keep the higher plan for that billing period and at least the next two before you can move back down. Growth users who regularly pass 2,000 minutes get a custom-volume plan. So for your busiest month, price the next plan up for three months, not extra minutes.
Are any of these on long contracts?
No. Ruby says no long-term contracts. Smith.ai's plans are month-to-month, with a 10% discount for a 12-month human subscription. Rosie offers a 7-day free trial and says you can cancel anytime. Read each cancellation clause yourself before you sign.
Can I mix AI for routine calls and humans for the rest?
Yes, and for many small firms that is the cheapest safe set-up. Smith.ai sells both AI and human plans, and Ruby says optional AI enhancements come with its plans at no extra cost. Check how calls are handed from one to the other before you rely on it.
How much does a virtual receptionist cost per call?
At 50 to 200 calls a month, about $1.50 to $2.13 a call on Smith.ai's AI plans and about $0.50 to $1.50 on Rosie, against about $9 to $11 for Smith.ai's human receptionists and roughly $7 to $17 on Ruby. These are normalised from list prices, not quotes, and Ruby's figure depends on call length.
Is an AI receptionist cheaper than a human one?
Yes, by a wide margin on list prices. The page's sums put Smith.ai's human plans at about five times its AI plans per call at every volume. The cheaper services do less, though, so judge whether your calls need a person who calms a worried caller and takes a detailed message.
Further reads
- How Much Does Ruby Receptionist Cost? Minute Plans Explained — Ruby's 50, 100, 200 and 500 minute plans explained.
- Rosie vs Smith.ai for a One-Person Business: Which Costs Less? — Which costs less for a one-person business.
- How Much Does Smith.ai Cost per Month? AI vs Human at 60 Calls — Smith.ai human or AI at 60 calls a month.
- Ruby Receptionist vs AI Receptionist: Is Ruby Legit and Worth It? — Whether Ruby is worth it next to an AI receptionist.
- What Is an AI Receptionist and How Does It Handle Bookings? — How an AI receptionist handles bookings.
- What to Do When an AI Receptionist Gets a Booking Wrong — What to do when an AI receptionist gets a booking wrong.
Show 7 more related tutorials
- AI Receptionist Pricing for Medical Offices: Per Minute or Booking — Per-minute, per-call and per-caller AI receptionist pricing compared for a medical office, with worked monthly costs, overage rules and BAA gating.
- Goodcall Alternatives: When Per-Caller Billing Stops Paying — Where Goodcall's unique-caller billing stops being cheapest, with Rosie, Dialzara and Smith.ai priced for the same 600-caller month.
- How Much Does Retell AI Cost per Minute for a Phone Agent? — Retell AI's per-minute price built part by part, a worked 900-minute month, the builder fee on top, and how it compares with Goodcall and Smith.ai.
- RingCentral AI Receptionist in the UK, EU and Australia: Add-On Only — Where the RingCentral AI Receptionist can be bought on its own, where it needs a RingEX plan, and what to do if you do not want the phone system.
- How Much Does Sameday AI Cost? Launch vs Scale for Trades Firms — Launch $449 for 500 minutes, Scale $789 for 1,000: what a plumbing firm and an HVAC firm would actually use on each plan.
- Does Smith.ai Have a Free Trial? The 25-Call Free Plan Explained — A free plan, not a trial: 25 real calls a month plus test and simulated calls, then $3.00 each. How to use it and when to move up.
- Smith.ai vs Ruby: Which Is Cheaper for a Two-Person Office? — Ruby sells human receptionist minutes, Smith.ai's AI sells calls. Here is where each wins for a two-person office, with break-even call counts.
Browse all AI-for-business tutorials
Sources: Ruby pricing and FAQ pages, Smith.ai pricing and AI receptionist pricing pages, and Rosie pricing page, all read this month.
